Water From Your Eyes Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Trying to chart the discography of Water From Your Eyes is a fascinating challenge.

The duo of Nate Amos and Rachel Brown have consistently crafted a sound that defies easy categorization. It's a journey through experimental pop, jarring dance-punk, and moments of surprising melodic clarity.

Here, we're creating a guide to the Water From Your Eyes albums ranked, using fan sentiment as our primary compass. This approach helps reveal which records have truly connected with their audience.

We'll also look at which releases are currently the most popular to offer another perspective on what might be the best Water From Your Eyes album.

Ranking Water From Your Eyes's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Somebody Else's Song (2019)

Released in 2019, Somebody Else's Song was the third full-length album from the duo.

This record arrived as the band was truly honing its unique sonic identity, building on the foundation of their earlier work while pushing into new territories.

Key tracks:

• Adeleine
• Somebody Else's Song

Securing the top spot, Somebody Else's Song clearly holds a special place for the dedicated fanbase.

Its position suggests it captures an essential, beloved era of the band's sound that continues to resonate deeply with listeners.

---

2. Everyone's Crushed (2023)

Everyone's Crushed marked the band's debut on the influential Matador Records label.

The 2023 album was met with widespread positive reviews from critics, earning a "universal acclaim" score on Metacritic based on numerous reviews.

Critics like Heather Phares of AllMusic noted that the band continued to level up their genre-mashing sound, calling the album their most consistently gripping music yet.

Key tracks:

• Barley
• True Life

This album's high ranking reflects its significant impact. It brought the band to a wider audience without sacrificing their experimental edge.

The critical praise and the band's refined, chaotic energy clearly translated into major fan appreciation.

---

3. Structure (2021)

Structure is a 2021 studio album that received positive attention for its unique and deliberate arrangement.

The album's recording coincided with the end of the romantic relationship between Nate Amos and Rachel Brown, adding a layer of personal history to the music.

Its song pattern was inspired by Scott Walker's Climate of Hunter, showing a deep commitment to artistic construction.

Key tracks:

• When You're Around
• Track Five

As a critical favorite that solidified the band's reputation, Structure is a cornerstone of their discography for many fans.

Its blend of cryptic indie pop and catchy elements makes it a rewarding and complex listen that stands out in their catalog.

---

4. All a Dance (2018)

Released in 2018, All a Dance was the duo's second full-length album.

This record continued the musical collaboration between Nate Amos and Rachel Brown, further developing the sound they established on their debut.

It stands as an important step in their journey toward the more complex works that would follow.

Key tracks:

• That's the Girl
• We're Set Up

All a Dance represents a key evolutionary point for the band.

Fans who appreciate the group's journey often point to this album as a crucial and creative moment in their early discography.

---

5. Long Days, No Dreams (2016)

This 2016 release served as the official debut album for Water From Your Eyes.

As the first full-length project from Amos and Brown, it laid the groundwork for their entire musical path.

The album showcases the initial sparks of the experimental and collaborative energy that would define their later work.

Key tracks:

• Cold Stare
• The Late Night Show

As the band's starting point, Long Days, No Dreams holds a foundational place in their story.

While their sound has evolved significantly, this debut is cherished by longtime fans for its raw potential and early glimpse into their creative partnership.

---

6. Structure Demos (2022)

This 2022 release offers a behind-the-scenes look at the creation of their album Structure.

The collection features early, unrefined versions of the songs, providing insight into the band's writing and recording process.

Key tracks:

• When You're Around (Demo)
• Stepping Out

Demo albums are typically for the most dedicated followers.

Its place in the ranking makes sense, as it's a supplementary piece valued by fans who want to explore the creative process behind a beloved record.

---

7. It's a Beautiful Place (2025)

Released in August 2025, It's a Beautiful Place is the band's latest studio album.

Following the success of Everyone's Crushed, this album continues their partnership with Matador Records.

The lead single "Life Signs" was released in June 2025, offering the first taste of their new material.

Key tracks:

• Life Signs
• Nights in Armor

As an new album, its ranking is mostly based on anticipation.

It's a placeholder for what's to come, with its true place in the hearts of fans yet to be determined.

---

8. 33:44 (2020)

33:44 is an experimental project released in 2020.

Comprising three long-form tracks, the album delves into more ambient and abstract soundscapes.

It highlights the band's willingness to explore beyond traditional song structures.

Key tracks:

• 15:00
• 2:27

Deeply experimental works like 33:44 often find a niche audience.

While respected for its artistic ambition, its less conventional format places it as a piece for fans interested in the band's most avant-garde inclinations.

---

Picked your top Water From Your Eyes classic? Check out Water From Your Eyes's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Water From Your Eyes albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Water From Your Eyes's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Somebody Else's Song	2019
2	It's a Beautiful Place	2025
3	Structure	2021
4	Everyone's Crushed	2023
5	All a Dance	2018
6	Long Days, No Dreams	2016
7	Structure Demos	2022
8	33:44	2020

Quick FAQs about Water From Your Eyes's albums

Q: What style of music does Water From Your Eyes play?

A: Their music has been described with many labels, including art rock and experimental pop. The band itself often describes their sound as dance-punk.

Q: Who are some of Water From Your Eyes's influences?

A: The duo has cited a diverse range of influences. This includes the band Ween and the work of Scott Walker, particularly his album Climate of Hunter.

---

So, that's our deep look at the Water From Your Eyes albums ranked by fans and by data.

Each record offers a different window into their creative world. The fan favorites highlight the core of their appeal, while the popularity data shows what's currently making waves.

Ultimately, the best Water From Your Eyes album is the one that connects with you personally. Their music is made for individual discovery.

What does your ranking look like?