Hot Mulligan Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Ranking the discography of a band as beloved as Hot Mulligan is always a fascinating exercise.

Each album holds a different meaning for every listener, tied to specific moments and memories.

For this list of Hot Mulligan albums ranked, we're putting fan sentiment at the forefront. We've looked at community discussions and general consensus to see which records truly resonate the most. This gives us a great look at what many consider the best Hot Mulligan albums.

We'll also check how popularity data stacks up later.

Ranking Hot Mulligan's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Why Would I Watch (2023)

Why Would I Watch is the third studio album from the Michigan emo group.

It was released in May 2023 through Wax Bodega.

This record saw the band honing their signature sound with even more confidence and polish.

Key tracks:

• No Shoes in the Coffee Shop (Or Socks)
• Shhhh! Golf is On

Topping the fan-voted list, Why Would I Watch clearly made an immediate and lasting impact on the Hot Mulligan fanbase.

Its combination of sharp songwriting and explosive energy represents the band at the peak of their powers, making it a modern classic for listeners.

---

2. you'll be fine (2020)

Released in March 2020, you'll be fine is the second studio album from Hot Mulligan.

The record was released through No Sleep Records.

It received generally positive reviews from critics, who noted its strong emotional core and melodic sound.

Key tracks:

• *Equip Sunglasses*
• BCKYRD

As a very close second, you'll be fine is an essential part of the band's story for many fans.

Its cathartic anthems and memorable lyrics have given it incredible staying power, cementing it as a foundational record in their catalog.

---

3. Pilot (2018)

Pilot is the debut full-length album from Hot Mulligan, released in 2018.

This album established the band's presence in the emo scene.

It was their first LP with No Sleep Records and followed several successful EPs.

Key tracks:

• How Do You Know It’s Not Armadillo Shells?
• Deluxe Capacitor

This record holds a special place for longtime followers of the band.

Pilot captured the raw, frantic energy that first drew fans in, and many of its tracks remain essential staples of their live shows.

---

4. Opportunities (2016)

Originally released in 2016, the Opportunities EP was a crucial early work for the band.

It was later re-released and remastered in 2017 after the band signed with No Sleep Records.

This collection of songs helped build the foundation for their future full-length albums.

Key tracks:

• Dary
• I Replied To Tyler With Three Blue Cars

While technically an EP, Opportunities is often discussed alongside their albums because of its importance.

For fans who were there from the beginning, this release is a cherished document of the band's developing sound and potential.

---

5. The Sound a Body Makes When It's Still (2025)

Released in August 2025, this is the band's fourth studio album.

The album was released through Wax Bodega.

It represents the next chapter for the Michigan group.

Key tracks:

• It Smells Like Fudge Axe in Here
• Moving to Bed Bug Island

As a forthcoming release, its position here is naturally based on anticipation rather than established fan consensus.

The excitement for this new era is high, and fans are eager to see where the band's sound goes next.

---

Picked your top Hot Mulligan classic? Check out Hot Mulligan's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Hot Mulligan albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Hot Mulligan's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	you'll be fine	2020
2	Why Would I Watch	2023
3	The Sound a Body Makes When It's Still	2025
4	Pilot	2018
5	Opportunities	2016

So there you have it, a comprehensive look at Hot Mulligan's albums ranked.

We've explored the passionate choices of the fan community and the current trends shown by popularity data.

Of course, the "best" Hot Mulligan album is always a matter of personal connection. Each one offers something unique.

What does your ranking look like?