Surf Curse Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Ranking the discography of Surf Curse is a fascinating exercise.
The band's journey from lo-fi garage rock to a more polished sound creates a lot of debate among listeners.
Here, we explore the Surf Curse albums ranked according to the fans. We use community sentiment to determine which records resonate the most.
This gives us a great look at what many feel are the best Surf Curse albums, and we will also see how they stack up based on popularity data.
Ranking Surf Curse's albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.
We're starting with the most beloved.
1. Heaven Surrounds You (2019)
The band's third studio album, Heaven Surrounds You, represented a significant step forward in their sound.
It was praised for Nick Rattigan's strong vocal performances and its more refined production quality.
The lead track "Disco" became a standout, noted for its energetic pace. Lyrically, the album also contains deeply moving moments, particularly on the closing track "Jamie."
Key tracks:
- Maps to The Stars
- Midnight Cowboy
Landing the top spot in our fan ranking, Heaven Surrounds You is often seen as Surf Curse at their most complete.
It balances the raw energy of their earlier work with a newfound polish and emotional depth, making it a clear favorite for many dedicated listeners.
2. Buds (2015)
Buds was the band's debut full-length album, released independently in their early years.
This record features the song "Freaks," a track written when the members were just 18 years old.
Years after its release, "Freaks" gained massive, unexpected popularity on TikTok, introducing the band to a huge new audience.
Key tracks:
- In My Head Till I'm Dead
- Goth Babe
For many early fans, Buds is the essential Surf Curse record. Its raw, unpolished sound captures the youthful energy that defined their beginnings.
Its high placement shows a deep appreciation for the band's roots and the album that started it all.
3. Nothing Yet (2017)
The band's second album, Nothing Yet, continued to build on their sound while drawing heavy inspiration from movies.
The members described the record as a reflection of their cinematic influences.
They even noted that a song like "The Strange and the Kind" could easily fit onto the soundtrack of a modern film.
Key tracks:
- Nostalgia
- All Is Lost
Nothing Yet holds a special place as the bridge between their raw debut and their more polished later work.
Fans who appreciate the band's knack for creating evocative, soundtrack-like moods often point to this album as an underrated gem in the discography.
4. Magic Hour (2022)
Magic Hour marked a major turning point for Surf Curse.
It was their first album released on a major label, Atlantic Records, and the first recorded as a four-piece band with the addition of Noah Kholl and Henry Dillon.
The album was received positively by critics, who saw it as a creative evolution of the band's talent and sound.
Key tracks:
- Sugar
- Arrow
While Magic Hour is seen as a strong and mature effort, its position in the fan ranking might reflect a division among listeners.
Some fans fully embrace the bigger, cleaner sound, while others may remain more attached to the lo-fi charm of the band's earlier projects.
Picked your top Surf Curse classic? Check out Surf Curse's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.
Surf Curse albums: A look at popularity data
While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.
This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.
Below is a ranking of Surf Curse's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.
| Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Buds | 2015 |
| 2 | Heaven Surrounds You | 2019 |
| 3 | Nothing Yet | 2017 |
| 4 | Magic Hour | 2022 |
Quick FAQs about Surf Curse's albums
Q: What song from Surf Curse became popular on TikTok?
A: The band has had two major songs go viral. "Freaks" from the album Buds saw a massive resurgence in 2020, followed by "Disco" from Heaven Surrounds You in 2024.
Q: When did Surf Curse become a four-piece band?
A: Surf Curse officially expanded to a four-member band before the release of their 2022 album, Magic Hour, adding Henry Dillon and Noah Kholl.
So, we have a clear look at the Surf Curse albums ranked.
Fan sentiment puts the refined emotion of Heaven Surrounds You at the top, while popularity data highlights the incredible staying power of Buds.
Ultimately, the best Surf Curse album is the one that connects with you personally.
What does your ranking look like?