They Are Gutting a Body of Water Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Trying to rank the discography of They Are Gutting a Body of Water is a fascinating task. Their music is a dense, rewarding blend of noise, texture, and unexpected melody.
Each album offers a unique and challenging experience. This makes pinpointing the "best" They Are Gutting a Body of Water album a topic of endless debate among fans.
Here, we present the They Are Gutting a Body of Water albums ranked according to fan sentiment and community discussion.
We will also look at how their catalog stacks up based on current popularity data.
Ranking They Are Gutting a Body of Water's albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.
We're starting with the most beloved.
1. Destiny XL (2019)
Released in 2019, Destiny XL is a landmark record for the band. It was recorded in a former house show venue in West Philadelphia, which may contribute to its raw, visceral sound.
The album draws inspiration from diverse sources. Songwriter Douglas Dulgarian has cited William Gibson's book Neuromancer as a specific influence on its themes and atmosphere.
Critics praised its unique ability to evoke specific feelings from its sonic blur. WXPN described it as "a homage to the unknown, to the visceral, and to the things that haunt us."
Key tracks:
- eightball
- 63 skies
Securing the top spot, Destiny XL is often seen as the definitive They Are Gutting a Body of Water experience for many listeners.
Its powerful fusion of overwhelming shoegaze and intricate electronic beats seems to capture the core of their appeal, making it an essential record in their catalog.
2. gestures been (2018)
The band's first proper studio album, gestures been, arrived in 2018. It laid the foundation for the sonic explorations that would follow.
This release established the project's move from a solo endeavor by Douglas Dulgarian into a more formidable band unit.
The album introduced the core elements of their sound. It blends heavy shoegaze textures with a distinct lo-fi sensibility that feels both intimate and expansive.
Key tracks:
- jadakiss
- fake twenty
As the band's official debut, gestures been holds a special place for many early supporters.
Its high ranking reflects an appreciation for the raw blueprint of their sound. It's a snapshot of a band discovering its immense power.
3. s (2022)
Known in many circles as lucky styles, this 2022 album saw the band push their creative boundaries even further.
The record was praised for its loose and uninhibited creativity. NPR described it as "a twisted tour of the band's every impulse," showcasing their wide range of influences.
This album prominently features breakcore and ambient interludes, which are often played from a sampler during the band's live shows.
Key tracks:
- 23 til infinity
- kmart amen break
The placement of s suggests it resonates deeply with fans who admire the band's most experimental side.
It's an album that rewards close listening, celebrated for its bold refusal to stick to a single genre or sound.
4. LOTTO (2025)
Released on October 17, 2025, LOTTO marks a significant new chapter for They Are Gutting a Body of Water.
This is the band's first album released on the acclaimed label ATO Records. The move signals a new level of recognition for their unique sound.
Key tracks:
- the chase
- american food
For an new album to rank this high speaks volumes about the anticipation within the fanbase.
The strength of the lead singles has generated considerable excitement, placing LOTTO firmly on the radar as a potentially major release for the band.
Picked your top They Are Gutting a Body of Water classic? Check out They Are Gutting a Body of Water's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.
They Are Gutting a Body of Water albums: A look at popularity data
Support Our Work
Listen great music, try 30 days of Amazon Music Unlimited on us. You get access to more than 100 million songs, we get a small kickback too.
Claim Your Free MonthWhile fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.
This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.
Below is a ranking of They Are Gutting a Body of Water's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.
| Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Destiny XL | 2019 |
| 2 | gestures been | 2018 |
| 3 | s | 2022 |
| 4 | swanlike (loosies 2020-2023) | 2024 |
| 5 | LOTTO | 2025 |
Quick FAQs about They Are Gutting a Body of Water's albums
Q: What genres does They Are Gutting a Body of Water incorporate into their music?
A: While their core sound is shoegaze, the band is known for pulling from drum and bass, breakcore, jungle, and even reggaeton.
Q: What were some key influences on the fan-favorite album, Destiny XL?
A: The band cited the Philadelphia band Blue Smiley as a major influence on their sound, and William Gibson's book Neuromancer was a specific influence on Destiny XL.
That completes our journey through They Are Gutting a Body of Water's albums ranked by fans.
Both fan consensus and popularity data provide valuable perspectives, but they are just starting points for discussion.
The best They Are Gutting a Body of Water album is ultimately the one that connects with you the most. Each record offers a dense and unique world to explore.
What does your personal ranking look like?