The Antlers Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Ranking the music of The Antlers is a uniquely personal task.

Their albums often feel less like collections of songs and more like complete, immersive emotional experiences.

For this list of The Antlers albums ranked, we're turning to the collective voice of the fans. This ranking is guided by community sentiment to see what many consider the best

The Antlers album. We'll also look at how their discography stacks up by popularity data.

Ranking The Antlers's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Hospice (2009)

Hospice is the band's third studio album and their first, and most famous, concept album.

The record tells the devastating story of a relationship between a hospice worker and a terminally ill patient, serving as a metaphor for an abusive relationship.

Initially self-distributed, it was later remastered and re-released by Frenchkiss Records, earning widespread critical acclaim.

Key tracks:

• Kettering
• Sylvia

It is no surprise to see Hospice at the top of this fan ranking. For many, it's not just The Antlers's best album; it's a landmark record in indie music.

Its raw, narrative-driven emotional power creates a listening experience that is profoundly moving and unforgettable, cementing its place in the hearts of listeners.

2. In the Attic of the Universe (2007)

The band's second album, In the Attic of the Universe, was created when The Antlers was still a solo project for Peter Silberman.

Silberman recorded the album alone, finding comfort in his fascination with the universe during a low point in his life.

This results in a record with recurring cosmic themes and a sense of quiet, intimate exploration.

Key tracks:

• The Universe Is Going To Catch You
• Stairs to the Attic

Securing the second spot, In the Attic of the Universe is deeply cherished by long-time fans.

Its lo-fi, deeply personal nature offers a glimpse into the project's origins, and its cosmic, gentle sound provides a different kind of emotional resonance.

3. Burst Apart (2011)

Burst Apart was the highly anticipated follow-up to the monumental Hospice.

The album saw the band expand their sound, moving into more atmospheric and electronic-tinged rock territory.

It was widely considered a successful evolution, earning critical praise for its sophisticated and dynamic textures.

Key tracks:

• Putting The Dog To Sleep
• I Don't Want Love

Coming in at number three, Burst Apart is often celebrated for how it masterfully navigated the pressure of following a classic.

Fans appreciate its lush production and the way it retained the band's emotional core while exploring a wider, more nuanced sonic palette.

4. Familiars (2014)

The band's fifth studio album, Familiars, is a slow-burning and majestic release.

Recorded in their own Brooklyn studio, the album is marked by its deliberate pace, rich brass instrumentation, and existential themes.

Critics praised it as a magnificent and beautiful work that turned heavy subject matter into something transcendent.

Key tracks:

• Palace
• Parade

Familiars holds a respected place in the discography, appreciated by fans who connect with its patient and contemplative nature.

Its layered, jazz-inflected arrangements reward dedicated listening and reveal immense depth over time.

5. Green To Gold (2021)

Released after a seven-year hiatus, Green To Gold marked a significant shift in the band's sound.

The album moves away from the intense, dark atmospheres of their earlier work.

Instead, it embraces a warm, pastoral feel with organic instruments and minimal arrangements, reflecting themes of aging and personal growth.

Key tracks:

• Green to Gold
• Solstice

The band's most recent full-length before this year, Green To Gold, finds its place in the middle of the fan ranking.

Its gentle, sunnier disposition is a departure that some fans have fully embraced, while others may still gravitate toward the towering melancholy of the band's earlier material.

6. Uprooted (2006)

Uprooted is the debut studio album from The Antlers, self-released online in 2006.

This early work was heavily inspired by the lo-fi recording techniques of artists like Phil Elverum of The Microphones.

It showcases the raw beginnings of Peter Silberman's songwriting and production style.

Key tracks:

• First Field
• Nashua

The band's debut, Uprooted, is a fascinating document of their origins, though it sits lower in the fan ranking.

Listeners who discover it later in their journey with the band can appreciate the seeds of what was to come, even if it lacks the polish of their later albums.

7. Blight (2025)

Blight is the band's seventh studio album, released in the fall of 2025.

The record was inspired by frontman Peter Silberman's walks near his home studio.

Its lyrics directly address themes of climate change and humanity's impact on the natural world.

Key tracks:

• Blight
• Carnage

As the newest entry in their catalog, Blight is still finding its long-term place among fans.

Its direct, topical lyrics are a notable evolution, and time will tell how this urgent album settles into the broader context of their celebrated discography.

8. Impermanence (2017)

While technically a solo album from Peter Silberman, Impermanence is intrinsically linked to the story of The Antlers.

It was created during the band's hiatus, as Silberman dealt with a significant hearing condition that made him question his ability to continue making music.

The result is an incredibly sparse, quiet, and intimate record that uses silence as a key instrument.

Key tracks:

• New York
• Karuna

Impermanence rounds out the list, and its position is understandable given its status as a solo work with a very specific, stark sound.

For fans who connect with its quiet fragility, it's a powerful statement. However, its minimalist approach sets it apart from the grander scope of the full band's albums.

Picked your top The Antlers classic? Check out The Antlers's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

The Antlers albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of The Antlers's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Quick FAQs about The Antlers's albums

Q: What is the concept behind The Antlers's album Hospice?

A: Hospice tells the story of an emotionally abusive relationship through the metaphor of a hospice worker and a female patient with terminal bone cancer.

Q: Did Sharon Van Etten sing on Hospice?

A: Yes, Sharon Van Etten provided guest vocals on several tracks, including "Kettering," "Thirteen," "Two," and "Shiva."

Ranking the work of The Antlers is a journey through some truly powerful music.

The fan ranking shows a deep love for the band's narrative-heavy, emotionally raw origins, while the popularity data gives us a snapshot of what's currently resonating.

But the best The Antlers album is always the one that speaks to you the most. Each record offers a unique and profound world to explore.

What's your take on The Antlers albums ranked? Let us know which one is your number one in the comments.