Sum 41 Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Sum 41's discography is a testament to evolution. They charged onto the scene with skate-punk anthems before diving headfirst into darker, metal-infused territory.
This journey has created a passionate and diverse fanbase with strong opinions. So, which release is considered the best Sum 41 album?
We're exploring the Sum 41 albums ranked by the people who know them best: the fans. This ranking is guided by community sentiment and discussion, offering a unique look at the band's legacy.
We'll also see how popularity data tells a different part of the story.
Ranking Sum 41's albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.
We're starting with the most beloved.
1. Chuck (2004)
The band's third studio album, Chuck, marked a significant shift in their sound. The lyrical content grew darker and more mature than their previous work.
Musically, it blended punk rock and melodic hardcore with heavy metal, creating a more aggressive and complex record.
The album was named after Chuck Pelletier, a UN peacekeeper who helped the band evacuate their hotel during an outbreak of fighting in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The experience deeply influenced the album's tone.
Chuck was a commercial and critical success, winning a Juno Award for "Rock Album of the Year" in 2005.
Key tracks:
- Pieces
- No Reason
Topping our fan-driven ranking, Chuck is often hailed as Sum 41's magnum opus. It represents the perfect fusion of their punk energy and a newfound metallic intensity.
For many listeners, this album is the moment the band truly came into their own, balancing raw power with sophisticated songwriting that has cemented its legacy.
2. Underclass Hero (2007)
Following the departure of guitarist Dave Baksh, Sum 41 recorded Underclass Hero as a three-piece. This album marked a deliberate return to the pop-punk sound of their earlier work.
The album was a commercial success, becoming the band's highest-charting record in the U.S. and hitting number one in Canada.
Critical reception was mixed, with some praising its mature songwriting while others found it derivative of other major punk albums of the era.
Key tracks:
- With Me
- Underclass Hero
Coming in at number two, Underclass Hero holds a special place for a large part of the fanbase. Its return to a more melodic, hook-driven style resonated deeply with those who loved the band's initial sound.
The album's personal and political lyrics, combined with its catchy anthems, make it a powerful and memorable statement in their catalog.
3. Half Hour Of Power (2000)
Considered an EP by some and a debut album by others, Half Hour of Power was Sum 41's explosive introduction to the world.
The release captures the band's raw, unfiltered energy, mixing skate punk with surprising hints of traditional heavy metal, particularly on tracks like "Grab the Devil..."
It set the stage for their breakthrough, with a re-recorded version of the track "Summer" appearing on their next album.
Key tracks:
- Makes No Difference
- Summer
The high fan ranking for Half Hour of Power speaks to a deep appreciation for the band's roots. This record is pure, youthful energy bottled into a short, sharp collection of songs.
Fans often praise its authenticity and the fearless blend of punk, metal, and humor that would become a Sum 41 trademark.
4. 13 Voices (2016)
13 Voices is a comeback album in every sense of the word. It marked the return of guitarist Dave "Brownsound" Baksh and was the first to feature drummer Frank Zummo.
The album was crowd-funded through a PledgeMusic campaign, showcasing the deep connection between the band and their supporters.
Released on Hopeless Records, it presented the band's first-ever five-piece lineup and was lauded by critics as a triumphant return to form.
Key tracks:
- War
- Fake My Own Death
This album's solid fan ranking is fueled by the powerful narrative behind it. 13 Voices isn't just a collection of songs; it's a story of resilience and rebirth.
Fans celebrate the return of Dave Baksh and the explosive, modern metal sound that proved Sum 41 was still a vital force in rock music.
5. Screaming Bloody Murder (2011)
The band's fifth studio album, Screaming Bloody Murder, was produced by frontman Deryck Whibley and faced numerous delays before its release.
It was the final album to feature original drummer Steve Jocz. Though guitarist Tom Thacker had joined the band, Whibley handled all guitar parts in the studio.
The album received mixed reviews and earned a Grammy nomination for Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance for the song "Blood in My Eyes."
Key tracks:
- Screaming Bloody Murder
- Jessica Kill
Screaming Bloody Murder is often seen as one of the band's most turbulent and darkest records. Its position in the ranking reflects its divisive nature.
While some fans embrace its raw, chaotic energy and emotional depth, others find it less cohesive than the albums surrounding it. It remains a fascinating and challenging listen.
6. All Killer, No Filler (2001)
Sum 41's official debut studio album, All Killer No Filler, was their commercial breakthrough. It launched the band into the global spotlight.
The album was certified platinum in the U.S., Canada, and the UK. Its lead single, "Fat Lip," became a defining anthem of the early 2000s pop-punk scene, topping the Billboard Alternative Airplay chart.
Despite mixed initial reviews, the album has since been recognized as a classic of the pop-punk genre.
Key tracks:
- In Too Deep
- Fat Lip
It might seem surprising to see such an iconic album lower in the fan ranking. This often happens with breakthrough records.
While universally loved for its hits, dedicated fans sometimes gravitate more toward the albums that followed, which showcased the band's artistic growth and darker complexities.
7. Does This Look Infected? (2002)
Released just a year after their breakthrough, Does This Look Infected? saw Sum 41 quickly pivot to a more aggressive and heavier sound.
The album shed some of the pop-punk elements in favor of a darker, punk rock and melodic hardcore style, with lyrical themes touching on more serious topics.
It served as a crucial transitional record, bridging the gap between the sound of All Killer No Filler and the heavy metal direction of Chuck.
Key tracks:
- Still Waiting
- The Hell Song
This album's placement highlights a common split in fan opinion. For many, it's a beloved step toward the band's heavier identity and contains some of their best singles.
However, for others, it exists in the shadow of the more polished pop-punk of its predecessor and the fully-realized metal of its successor, making it a transitional piece rather than a definitive statement.
8. Order In Decline (2019)
The band's seventh studio album, Order In Decline, continued the heavy and aggressive trajectory established on 13 Voices.
Whibley described the lyrics as a reflection of the social and political turmoil in North America, though he clarified it was not intended as a protest record.
The album was praised by critics as one of the band's heaviest and most dynamic efforts, blending punk rock, melodic hardcore, and alternative metal.
Key tracks:
- Out For Blood
- Never There
As a more recent release, Order In Decline is still finding its long-term place in the Sum 41 canon. Its ranking suggests it may be more appreciated by fans of the band's modern, metal-oriented sound.
While critically acclaimed for its intensity, it may not connect as broadly with listeners who favor the band's pop-punk era.
9. Heaven :x: Hell (2024)
Sum 41's eighth and final studio album, Heaven :x: Hell, is an ambitious double album. It serves as a farewell to their fans.
The first disc, Heaven, is a return to the pop-punk style of their early career. The second disc, Hell, embraces the heavy metal sound the band has cultivated in recent years.
On May 8, 2023, the band announced they would be disbanding following the album's release and a final world tour, making this record their definitive closing statement.
Key tracks:
- Landmines
- Dopamine
As the band's final and newest album, the legacy of Heaven :x: Hell is still being written. Its current ranking reflects that it is still fresh in the minds of listeners.
The dual-sided concept is a gift to all eras of the fanbase, but it will take time for the community to fully absorb this epic farewell and decide where it stands among the classics.
Picked your top Sum 41 classic? Check out Sum 41's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.
Sum 41 albums: A look at popularity data
Support Our Work
Listen great music, try 30 days of Amazon Music Unlimited on us. You get access to more than 100 million songs, we get a small kickback too.
Claim Your Free MonthWhile fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.
This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.
Below is a ranking of Sum 41's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.
| Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | All Killer, No Filler | 2001 |
| 2 | Does This Look Infected? | 2002 |
| 3 | Chuck | 2004 |
| 4 | Underclass Hero | 2007 |
| 5 | 13 Voices | 2016 |
| 6 | Heaven :x: Hell | 2024 |
| 7 | Order In Decline | 2019 |
| 8 | Half Hour Of Power | 2000 |
| 9 | Screaming Bloody Murder | 2011 |
Quick FAQs about Sum 41's albums
Q: Why is the album Chuck named that?
A: The album is named in honor of Chuck Pelletier. He was a UN peacekeeper who helped Sum 41 and other civilians evacuate a hotel during fighting in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Q: What makes Chuck sound different from their earlier albums?
A: It has a much heavier and more mature sound. The band intentionally mixed their punk rock style with strong heavy metal influences from bands like Metallica and Iron Maiden.
So there you have it – a look at Sum 41's albums ranked from two different perspectives.
Fan sentiment often elevates the records that represent a band's artistic peak, while popularity data highlights the breakthrough moments that brought them to the masses.
Ultimately, the best Sum 41 album is the one that connects with you. Each record captures a different chapter in their incredible career.
What does your personal ranking look like?