Say She She Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the discography of Say She She is like stepping into a time machine with a modern twist.

Their blend of "discodelic soul" and dreamy harmonies has created a dedicated following. But within that fanbase, a healthy debate always simmers: which album is the definitive Say She She experience?

To get to the heart of the matter, we're exploring the Say She She albums ranked according to the fans. This list is shaped by community sentiment and the lasting impact of each record.

We'll also look at a separate ranking based on current popularity data to see how the two compare. This is our deep look into what makes the best Say She She album.

Ranking Say She She's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Prism (2022)

As their debut album, Prism introduced the world to the trio's unique sound.

Released on Karma Chief/Colemine Records, the record immediately turned heads.

It earned a perfect five-star review from The Guardian, which praised it as a "delightful place to visit for half an hour." This critical acclaim mirrored the excitement building among new listeners.

Key tracks:

• Prism
• Fortune Teller

Holding the top spot, Prism is clearly a foundational record for the Say She She fanbase. It's the album that started it all, capturing the raw energy and chemistry of the group's formation.

For many, a debut album that arrives so fully formed and confident is impossible to top. It set the bar incredibly high from the very beginning.

---

2. Silver (2023)

Say She She's sophomore album, Silver, arrived just a year after their stunning debut.

The record was met with widespread positive reviews. Public radio station KCRW even ranked it as their number one album of 2023.

The band supported the album with an extensive tour, playing iconic venues like the Hollywood Bowl and major events like the Glastonbury Festival.

Key tracks:

• Forget Me Not
• Astral Plane

Coming in at a very close second, Silver proved that Say She She was no fluke. It’s an ambitious and expansive follow-up that solidified their place in the modern soul landscape.

Fans appreciate how the album builds on the foundation of Prism while exploring new textures and more complex arrangements. It's a sign of a band growing in confidence.

---

3. Cut & Rewind (2025)

Cut & Rewind, was written almost immediately after their whirlwind tours for Silver.

This album expands their sonic palette even further. It incorporates elements of no-wave and post-punk, channeling a spirit of righteous rebellion.

Songs like "She Who Dares" and "Disco Life" carry a politically charged undercurrent beneath their lush, strobing sonics.

The band maintained their raw, spontaneous energy by recording tracks right after writing them, often limiting themselves to just a few takes.

Key tracks:

• Shop Boy
• Cut & Rewind

As a recent release, Cut & Rewind naturally lands at the end of a fan-based ranking. It simply hasn't had the time to build the deep connection that the other albums have.

However, anticipation is incredibly high. Fans are eager to see how the band's sound will evolve on their third full-length project.

---

Picked your top Say She She classic? Check out Say She She's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Say She She albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Say She She's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Prism	2022
2	Silver	2023
3	Cut & Rewind	2025

Quick FAQs about Say She She's albums

Q: What kind of music does Say She She make?

A: They describe their sound as "discodelic soul," which features dreamy harmonies and a strong foundation in 70s funk and disco. They cite Nile Rodgers and Chic as major influences.

Q: Who are the members of Say She She?

A: The band is fronted by three classically trained singers: Piya Malik, Sabrina Mileo Cunningham, and Nya Gazelle Brown.

So there you have it – a look at the Say She She albums ranked by the people who know them best.

It's clear that their debut made a massive, lasting impression, while their sophomore effort is also deeply appreciated for its growth and ambition.

Of course, the "best" Say She She album is the one that connects with you the most. Each record offers a vibrant, soulful journey worth taking.

What does your ranking look like?