Poppy Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Poppy is an artist who defies easy categorization. Her musical journey is one of constant, radical evolution.

This makes any discussion about her discography fascinating. Trying to create a definitive list of Poppy albums ranked is a challenge, but one guided best by the listeners who have followed every twist and turn.

We're exploring her studio albums, with the primary ranking shaped by fan sentiment and community consensus. This helps us see what many consider the best Poppy albums. We will also look at how they stack up based on current popularity data.

Ranking Poppy's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. I Disagree (2020)

I Disagree is the third studio album from Poppy and her first with Sumerian Records. It also marked her final project with creative partner Titanic Sinclair.

The album was a seismic shift in sound, moving from pop into a dynamic blend of heavy metal and avant-garde styles. This new direction earned praise from critics.

It became Poppy's first album to chart on the Billboard 200. It also found success in the UK, debuting at the top of the Rock & Metal Albums Chart.

The single "BLOODMONEY" received a Grammy nomination for Best Metal Performance, a significant milestone for the artist.

Key tracks:

• I Disagree
• BLOODMONEY

Crowning our fan-voted list, I Disagree is widely seen as Poppy's definitive statement.

For many listeners, this album represents a powerful artistic liberation. Its aggressive, experimental, and genre-bending sound is what cemented her place as a unique force in modern music.

2. Negative Spaces (2024)

Poppy's sixth studio album, Negative Spaces, was released in late 2024 through Sumerian Records.

The record was produced by Jordan Fish, formerly of Bring Me the Horizon. It features a sound primarily rooted in metalcore and alternative rock.

Critics met the album with widespread acclaim. Many considered it a powerful return to form after the more mixed reception of her previous album, Zig.

Key tracks:

• new way out
• the cost of giving up

Securing the second spot, Negative Spaces was an immediate hit with fans.

Its focused, heavy, and emotionally raw approach resonated deeply. The album is often praised for its cohesive production and powerful songwriting, proving Poppy's metal inclinations were here to stay.

3. Flux (2021)

Released in 2021, Flux is Poppy's fourth studio album. The record was produced by Justin Meldal-Johnsen, known for his work with artists like Paramore and M83.

This album features a more organic, live-band sound. It draws heavily from alternative rock, grunge, and dream pop influences.

The shift was well-received by critics, who praised its earnest songwriting and authentic rock energy.

Key tracks:

• Her
• Flux

Flux holds a special place for many fans, landing it firmly in the top three.

While less abrasive than I Disagree, its raw, guitar-driven sound is celebrated. The album is often seen as a showcase of Poppy's versatility as a rock artist.

4. Poppy.Computer (2017)

Poppy.Computer, released in 2017, was Poppy's debut studio album. It served as the musical extension of her surreal YouTube persona at the time.

The sound is a distinct blend of bubblegum pop, synth-pop, and art pop. It explores themes of technology and internet culture with a satirical, android-like detachment.

The album established the initial lore and aesthetic that captivated her early audience.

Key tracks:

• I'm Poppy
• Moshi Moshi

This album is the origin point for many longtime fans.

While her sound has evolved dramatically, the conceptual creativity and catchy, synth-driven tracks of Poppy.Computer remain a nostalgic favorite. It laid the groundwork for everything that followed.

5. Zig (2023)

Poppy's fifth studio album, Zig, arrived in 2023. The record marked her return to Sumerian Records.

Produced by Ali Payami, the album saw Poppy revisiting pop music, this time with a darker, more industrial edge. It blends dark pop, electropop, and industrial sounds.

Reception was generally positive, though some critics and fans missed the heavier sounds of her recent work.

Key tracks:

• Church Outfit
• Knockoff

Zig is an interesting case in Poppy's discography, and its ranking reflects its divisive nature.

Some fans embraced the return to electronic and pop sensibilities, while others found the shift less compelling than her rock-oriented albums. This makes it one of her more debated releases.

6. Am I A Girl? (2018)

Released on Halloween in 2018, Am I a Girl? is Poppy's second studio album.

The record is primarily a dance-pop album, but its final tracks famously take a sharp turn into nu metal. This was the first major hint of the heavier direction she would later fully embrace.

The album features collaborations with Diplo and Grimes. Its blend of genres received polarized reviews from critics at the time.

Key tracks:

• Girls In Bikinis
• X

Am I a Girl? is a crucial transitional album, but it often gets caught in the middle for fans.

While tracks like "X" are fan-favorites, the overall record is sometimes seen as less cohesive than her other projects. It's a bridge between two distinct eras of her career.

7. 3:36 (Music to Sleep To) (2016)

Poppy's first full-length project was an ambient music album released in 2016.

Composed with Titanic Sinclair and polysomnographists, the album was designed to aid with sleep. It aligns with the conceptual, performance art nature of her early work.

Key tracks:

• Me Time Me
• Mind Aide

As a purely ambient record, 3:36 is naturally a niche entry in her discography.

While appreciated by some for its experimental nature, it's not a typical listening experience and therefore ranks lower in general fan discussions about her main albums.

8. I C U (Music to Read To) (2019)

This 2019 release is another of Poppy's ambient projects.

It was designed as a companion piece to her graphic novel, Genesis 1. The music is intended to be a soundtrack for the reading experience.

Key tracks:

• Circulate
• Centralize

Similar to her previous ambient album, I C U is more of a conceptual art piece than a traditional record.

Its specific purpose as a soundtrack for her graphic novel makes it an interesting part of her lore but less central to conversations about her musical evolution.

9. Music To Scream To (2020)

Released in 2020, this project is a noise and dark ambient album.

As the title suggests, the sound is harsh and experimental. It pushes the boundaries of conventional music, exploring texture and abrasive soundscapes.

Key tracks:

• Scream
• Screamm

This album is Poppy at her most experimental and challenging.

Its harsh, noisy aesthetic makes it the least accessible album for casual listeners. While it has its place as a bold artistic experiment, it's not one that most fans revisit regularly.

Picked your top Poppy classic? Check out Poppy's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

Poppy albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Poppy's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Quick FAQs about Poppy's albums

Q: What makes I Disagree a "post-genre" album?

A: The album incorporates a huge range of sounds. Critics have described it as everything from avant-garde and heavy metal to electropop, J-pop, and even thrash metal.

Q: Why was the album I Disagree seen as a rebirth for Poppy?

A: I Disagree was released after her creative split from collaborator Titanic Sinclair. It represented a major change in both her musical style and personal artistic control.

That completes our journey through Poppy's albums ranked by fans and by data.

The rankings show a clear appreciation for her heavier, more assertive work, but every album plays a key part in her story. The divide between the fan favorite, I Disagree, and the current most popular, Negative Spaces, tells a story of its own.

Ultimately, the best Poppy album is the one that connects with you. Which record from her eclectic discography stands out as your personal number one?