Pierce The Veil Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the Pierce The Veil discography always brings up passionate debate among fans.

Each album represents a specific era, a unique sound, and a collection of stories that resonate differently with everyone. It's a tough task, but we're here to look at the Pierce The Veil albums ranked.

Our primary ranking is guided by fan sentiment. We've looked at community discussions and the general consensus to see which records hold the most beloved spots. This gives us a great look at what many consider the best Pierce The Veil albums.

Ranking Pierce The Veil's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. A Flair For The Dramatic (2007)

This is the debut studio album from Pierce the Veil, released back in 2007.

The record was produced by Casey Bates alongside Vic Fuentes.

Interestingly, it was recorded with only the Fuentes brothers, Vic and Mike, handling all the instrument duties themselves. This gives the album a uniquely focused and raw feel.

Key tracks:

• Yeah Boy and Doll Face
• I'd Rather Die Than Be Famous

Taking the top spot, A Flair For The Dramatic holds a special place in the hearts of longtime fans.

As a debut, it represents the unfiltered origin of the band's sound. Its raw energy and foundational tracks are frequently cited as the reason it remains so essential to the fan base.

---

2. Selfish Machines (2010)

Released in 2010, Selfish Machines is the band's second studio album.

The album was recorded in Los Angeles with producer Mike Green. Vic Fuentes handled most of the songwriting, with some co-writing credits from Tom Denney of A Day to Remember.

It received favorable reviews for its lyricism and experimental approach, though some noted the use of Auto-Tune on certain tracks.

Key tracks:

• Caraphernelia
• Bulletproof Love

Coming in at number two, Selfish Machines is often seen as the album where the band truly refined its unique blend of post-hardcore and experimental rock.

Its iconic tracks and memorable collaborations, like Jeremy McKinnon's feature on "Caraphernelia," solidified its high standing among fans.

---

3. Collide With The Sky (2012)

Collide With The Sky marked the band's third studio release and their first with Fearless Records in 2012.

This album is known for spawning some of the band's biggest hits, which have become staples in their live shows.

The record was a commercial success, debuting at number 12 on the U.S. Billboard 200 and eventually earning a gold certification.

Key tracks:

• King For A Day
• A Match Into Water

This album is a powerhouse in the band's discography and a gateway for many new listeners.

Its position at number three reflects its immense popularity and impact, even if some die-hard fans slightly prefer the earlier works. It's an undeniable classic.

---

4. Misadventures (2016)

Misadventures, the fourth album, was released in 2016 after a few postponements.

It served as a follow-up to the highly successful Collide with the Sky and was produced by Dan Korneff.

The album's lyrics continue to explore personal experiences, but also touch on contemporary events, such as the Paris terrorist attacks in the song "Circles."

Key tracks:

• Circles
• Floral & Fading

This record saw the band navigating the immense expectations set by its predecessor.

While critically acclaimed and loved for its polished sound, its placement here suggests that for the core fanbase, it hasn't quite eclipsed the legacy of the first three albums.

---

5. The Jaws Of Life (2023)

Released in 2023, The Jaws of Life is the band's fifth and most recent studio album.

It's the first record not to feature drummer Mike Fuentes, with Brad Hargreaves of Third Eye Blind filling in.

The album takes influence from '90s grunge and nu-metal, presenting a sound that is more melodic and intimate than some of their previous work.

Key tracks:

• So Far So Fake
• Pass The Nirvana

As the newest entry, The Jaws Of Life is still finding its long-term place in the band's storied discography.

Its stylistic shift has been a topic of discussion among fans. While many praise the mature direction, its current fan ranking indicates that it may take more time to be fully embraced alongside the established classics.

---

Picked your top Pierce The Veil classic? Check out Pierce The Veil's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Pierce The Veil albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Pierce The Veil's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Collide With The Sky	2012
2	The Jaws Of Life	2023
3	Selfish Machines	2010
4	Misadventures	2016
5	A Flair For The Dramatic	2007

Quick FAQs about Pierce The Veil's albums

Q: Who played the instruments on Pierce The Veil's debut album?

A: A Flair for the Dramatic was recorded with only brothers Vic and Mike Fuentes. They handled all the instrument duties for the album themselves.

---

So, we have a complete look at Pierce The Veil's albums ranked by both fan love and current data.

The fan-favorite debut, A Flair For The Dramatic, and the massively popular Collide With The Sky tell two different but equally important stories about the band's journey.

Ultimately, the best Pierce The Veil album is the one that means the most to you.

What does your ranking look like?