Molly Tuttle Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Molly Tuttle's discography is a masterclass in modern bluegrass and Americana.

Her technical brilliance on the guitar is matched only by her thoughtful songwriting. But when it comes to her studio albums, which ones do fans hold closest?

We're exploring the Molly Tuttle albums ranked according to fan sentiment. This list reflects the buzz and passion from the community that follows her music closely. It helps us see what many consider to be the best Molly Tuttle album, before we look at the numbers from popularity data.

Ranking Molly Tuttle's albums: The fan favorites

Here is the definitive look at Molly Tuttle's studio albums, ranked from the top spot downwards based on fan reception and discussion.

We begin with the album that has captured the most hearts.

1. Crooked Tree (2022)

This album marked a triumphant return to Molly Tuttle's bluegrass roots.

Backed by her incredible band, Golden Highway, the record is a showcase of virtuoso playing and sharp songwriting.

The project was widely celebrated, earning Tuttle the Grammy Award for Best Bluegrass Album. It also secured a nomination for the all-genre Best New Artist award, a significant achievement.

Key tracks:

• Dooley's Farm (feat. Billy Strings)
• Crooked Tree

It’s no surprise to see Crooked Tree at the top of the fan ranking.

For many listeners, this album is the definitive Molly Tuttle statement. It's the record where her phenomenal guitar skills, heartfelt vocals, and storytelling all coalesced into a modern bluegrass classic.

---

2. City of Gold (2023)

Following the success of its predecessor, City of Gold continued the journey with her band Golden Highway.

The album was inspired by a year of heavy touring, which tightened the band's chemistry and cohesion. Co-produced by Tuttle and dobro legend Jerry Douglas, the record even features a collaboration with Dave Matthews.

Like its forerunner, this album also won the Grammy Award for Best Bluegrass Album, cementing a remarkable run for Tuttle and her band.

Key tracks:

• El Dorado
• San Joaquin

Placing a strong second, City of Gold is seen by fans as a fantastic and worthy follow-up.

It captures the sound of a band at the peak of their powers, building on the foundation of Crooked Tree while feeling confident and road-tested.

---

3. Rise (2017)

This seven-song EP was a crucial moment in Molly Tuttle's solo career.

After moving to Nashville, she launched a crowdfunding campaign to create this project, writing all the songs herself. The EP introduced the world to her singular voice as a bandleader and songwriter.

It was also the year she became the first woman to win the International Bluegrass Music Association's Guitar Player of the Year award.

Key tracks:

• Good Enough
• Save This Heart

For longtime fans, Rise holds a special place. It was the first substantial collection of original solo material that showcased the full range of her talents.

Its high ranking reflects the excitement and promise that this release generated, setting the stage for everything that came after.

---

4. When You're Ready (2019)

This was Tuttle's official full-length debut album, released via Compass Records.

The record saw her expanding her sound, incorporating elements that pushed beyond the boundaries of traditional bluegrass. It established her not just as an instrumentalist but as a well-rounded artist and songwriter.

This album helped solidify her reputation after she won the IBMA Guitar Player of the Year award for a second consecutive year in 2018.

Key tracks:

• Take The Journey
• When You're Ready

While her later work with Golden Highway gets much of the attention, When You're Ready remains a significant part of her catalog.

Fans appreciate it as a thoughtful, polished debut that showcases a different side of her artistry, one more rooted in singer-songwriter traditions.

---

5. ...but i'd rather be with you (2020)

Released in 2020, this album is a collection of cover songs.

Tuttle puts her unique spin on tracks from a diverse range of artists, showcasing her interpretive skills and musical influences.

The album demonstrates her ability to inhabit songs written by others and make them entirely her own, a testament to her versatility.

Key tracks:

• Sunflower, Vol. 6
• She's A Rainbow

Covers albums often occupy a unique space in an artist's discography.

While deeply appreciated for its artistry and fun selections, fans typically gravitate toward an artist's original compositions. This album is a beloved detour rather than a main-line destination, explaining its position in the ranking.

---

6. So Long Little Miss Sunshine (2025)

Tuttle's fifth studio album, So Long Little Miss Sunshine, was released in August 2025.

Produced by Jay Joyce, the project marks a significant stylistic evolution from her previous bluegrass-oriented work. It moves into a sound built on folk-pop, country, and rock foundations.

The album features contributions from her partner, Ketch Secor of Old Crow Medicine Show, and includes a cover of Icona Pop's "I Love It."

Key tracks:

• Everything Burns
• Summer of Love

As the newest and most stylistically adventurous album in her catalog, So Long Little Miss Sunshine is still finding its place among the fanbase.

Its ranking reflects that some listeners are still connecting with this bold new direction, while many others remain deeply attached to her celebrated bluegrass sound.

---

Picked your top Molly Tuttle classic? Check out Molly Tuttle's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Molly Tuttle albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Molly Tuttle's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Crooked Tree	2022
2	So Long Little Miss Sunshine	2025
3	City of Gold	2023
4	When You're Ready	2019
5	...but i'd rather be with you	2020
6	Rise	2017

Quick FAQs about Molly Tuttle's albums

Q: What major award did Molly Tuttle win for her album Crooked Tree?

A: In 2023, Molly Tuttle won the Grammy Award for Best Bluegrass Album for Crooked Tree. She was also nominated for the all-genre Best New Artist award that same year.

Q: Who is the band that plays with Molly Tuttle on Crooked Tree and City of Gold?

A: The band featured on both of those acclaimed albums is Golden Highway. The group was essential to the sound and success of that musical era for Tuttle.

---

So there you have it, a comprehensive look at the Molly Tuttle albums ranked by fans.

We've seen the community favorites and also considered the current popularity data, which sometimes tell different stories.

Ultimately, the best Molly Tuttle album is the one that connects with you the most. Each record is a snapshot of an incredible artist's evolving journey.

What does your personal ranking look like?