Freddie Gibbs Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Freddie Gibbs has carved out a remarkable career defined by technical skill and unflinching honesty. His discography is a testament to consistency, whether he's on his own or collaborating with legendary producers.

Because of this, putting the Freddie Gibbs albums ranked in order is a challenge. What is the best Freddie Gibbs album? The answer often depends on who you ask.

We're approaching this by listening to the fans first. This list is ranked by community sentiment, reflecting the projects that have resonated most deeply with listeners.

We'll also look at the numbers to see how they stack up by current popularity.

Ranking Freddie Gibbs's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Piñata (2014)

This is the first collaborative studio album between Freddie Gibbs and the iconic producer Madlib. The project was released in 2014 after being built up by a series of EPs.

Gibbs himself described the album as "a gangster Blaxploitation film on wax." It features an incredible lineup of guests, including Raekwon, Earl Sweatshirt, Danny Brown, and Scarface.

Upon its release, Piñata received widespread critical acclaim and has since become a landmark album in modern hip-hop.

Key tracks:

• Thuggin’
• High (feat. Danny Brown)

It's no surprise to see Piñata at the top. For many, this is the definitive Freddie Gibbs project and a flawless record from front to back.

The chemistry between Gibbs's hard-hitting bars and Madlib's dusty, cinematic beats created a sound that was both timeless and entirely new. It remains the high bar against which all his other work is measured.

---

2. Bandana (2019)

The highly anticipated follow-up to Piñata, Bandana reunited Freddie Gibbs and Madlib five years later. It was the second installment of a planned trilogy.

Gibbs stated he wrote much of the album while incarcerated, viewing it as a manifesto. The project features another stellar cast, with Pusha T, Killer Mike, Anderson .Paak, and Black Thought contributing.

Famously, Madlib revealed he made all the beats for Bandana on his iPad, showcasing his incredible talent for crafting complex soundscapes with minimal tools.

Key tracks:

• Crime Pays
• Fake Names

For some fans, Bandana is even better than its predecessor. It had the impossible task of following a classic, yet it delivered on every level.

The album feels tighter and more focused, with Gibbs sounding sharper and more reflective than ever. It solidified MadGibbs as one of the greatest rapper-producer duos of all time.

---

3. Fetti (2018)

Fetti is a three-way collaboration between Freddie Gibbs, fellow rapper Curren$y, and producer The Alchemist. The project came together quickly, with Gibbs reportedly recording his half in just two days.

Released on Halloween in 2018, the album was praised for the incredible synergy between the two distinct rappers and The Alchemist's moody, atmospheric production.

Key tracks:

• New Thangs
• Saturday Night Special

This album is a fan favorite because it's pure, uncut hip-hop excellence. It's a short, potent project with zero filler.

The effortless chemistry between Gibbs, Curren$y, and The Alchemist is the main draw. It feels like three masters at the peak of their craft linking up to create something special.

---

4. Alfredo (2020)

Alfredo marked the first full-length project between only Freddie Gibbs and The Alchemist. The album's title is a portmanteau of the two artists' names.

It features guest appearances from Rick Ross, Benny the Butcher, Tyler, the Creator, and Conway the Machine, connecting Gibbs with some of the best lyricists in the game.

The album was a huge success, earning a nomination for Best Rap Album at the Grammy Awards and becoming both artists' highest-charting album at the time.

Key tracks:

• 1985
• Something to Rap About (feat. Tyler, The Creator)

Earning the fourth spot, Alfredo is celebrated for its luxurious and cohesive feel. It's a masterclass in modern production and elite lyricism.

Fans appreciate the refined, cinematic quality of the album. Gibbs sounds completely at home over The Alchemist's beats, creating a project that is both gritty and sophisticated.

---

5. Shadow of a Doubt (2015)

Released in 2015, Shadow of a Doubt is the second official studio album from Freddie Gibbs. It followed the massive success of his collaboration with Madlib on Piñata.

The album showcases Gibbs's versatility, moving between different sounds and styles while maintaining his signature lyrical edge. It was met with positive reviews from critics, who praised his artistic restlessness.

Key tracks:

• Forever and a Day
• Fuckin' up the Count

Shadow of a Doubt holds a special place for many fans as a showcase of Gibbs's range as a solo artist.

While his producer collaborations often get the most attention, this album proved he could carry a diverse project on his own terms. It’s a record that reveals more with each listen.

---

6. Midwestgangstaboxframecadillacmuzik (2009)

This 2009 mixtape was released shortly after The Miseducation of Freddie Gibbs. Its title is a clever nod to Outkast's classic debut album.

Much of the material was recorded during Gibbs's time signed to Interscope Records. The project was released as a free download and helped solidify his reputation as a formidable new voice in rap.

Key tracks:

• Sumthin U Should Know
• Midwest Malcolm (Inhale)

For longtime fans, this mixtape is a crucial part of the Freddie Gibbs story. It represents the raw hunger of his early career.

This project captures a moment in time, showcasing the talent that would soon lead to his celebrated collaborative albums. It’s a foundational text in his catalog.

---

7. Freddie (2018)

This project is a commercial mixtape that Gibbs surprise-released in 2018. It arrived without any prior announcements, catching fans and critics off guard.

Freddie is a concise and aggressive project, clocking in with 10 tracks that showcase his commanding presence and sharp wit over a variety of trap-influenced beats.

The album received critical acclaim for its energy and focus, further proving Gibbs's ability to deliver high-quality work on his own schedule.

Key tracks:

• Automatic
• Death Row (feat. 03 Greedo)

The love for Freddie comes from its raw, unfiltered energy. It's a compact and explosive listen that doesn't waste a single second.

Fans appreciate it as a showcase of Gibbs just having fun and rapping at an elite level. It's a reminder that he doesn't need a high-concept framework to create a compelling project.

---

8. Cold Day In Hell (2012)

Released while he was signed to Young Jeezy's CTE World label, this mixtape was a major step in Gibbs's career. It helped introduce him to a much wider audience.

The project features guest spots from major artists like Juicy J and 2 Chainz. It received significant coverage from music publications and helped him land on XXL's coveted Freshman list.

Key tracks:

• Natural High (Even Higher Learning)
• Heaven Can Wait

This mixtape is respected as a key moment in Gibbs's ascent. It showed he could hang with the biggest names in the industry while staying true to his sound.

It's a snapshot of his grind, a project that paved the way for the artistic freedom he would later achieve with his independent releases.

---

9. Str8 Killa (2010)

Str8 Killa is the debut EP by Freddie Gibbs, released in 2010. It served as a commercial release for his mixtape, Str8 Killa No Filla, which dropped a week prior.

The project helped build early momentum for the Gary, Indiana rapper, showcasing his distinct flow and uncompromising lyrical content to a growing audience.

Key tracks:

• National Anthem (F…ack the World)
• Personal OG

As one of his earliest commercial projects, Str8 Killa is a raw and essential document of Gibbs's early sound.

It may not be as refined as his later work, but fans appreciate it for its authenticity and the glimpse it provides of the artist he was about to become.

---

10. You Only Die 1nce (2024)

This is the fifth solo studio album from Freddie Gibbs, released as a surprise at the end of 2024. It acts as a sequel to his 2017 album, You Only Live 2wice.

The album's promotion was cryptic, involving billboards and mysterious phone numbers with references to horror icons like Freddy Krueger.

Production on the project was handled by a diverse group of producers, including Bnyx and DJ Harrison.

Key tracks:

• Cosmo Freestyle
• 30 Girlfriends (Yeah Yeah)

Being one of his more recent releases, the legacy of You Only Die 1nce is still being written within the fan community.

Its placement here reflects that it's still finding its long-term place in a catalog filled with established classics. Time will tell how it stacks up against his most celebrated work.

---

11. You Only Live 2wice (2017)

Gibbs's third studio album was released in 2017 following a tumultuous period in his life. He had been arrested in France and later acquitted of all charges.

The album is a concise, eight-track project with no guest appearances. The title and cover art evoke themes of resurrection and rebirth, reflecting his return to music.

Key tracks:

• Alexys
• Andrea

This is arguably Gibbs's most personal and focused solo project. Its lean runtime and lack of features put his lyricism and storytelling front and center.

Fans who connect with You Only Live 2wice often praise its depth and the raw emotion born from a difficult chapter in his life. It’s a powerful statement of resilience.

---

12. Baby Face Killa (2012)

Baby Face Killa is the tenth mixtape by Freddie Gibbs and his entry into the iconic Gangsta Grillz series hosted by DJ Drama.

Released in 2012, it features an extensive list of guests, including Pharrell Williams, Jadakiss, Curren$y, and Young Jeezy. The track "Still Livin'" was famously included in the video game Grand Theft Auto V.

Key tracks:

• Still Livin'
• BFK

This mixtape is appreciated for its ambition and star-studded tracklist. It captures a specific era of mixtape culture perfectly.

While some fans find it less cohesive than his studio albums, its high points are incredibly strong and showcase Gibbs's ability to create hits.

---

13. Alfredo 2 (2025)

The sequel to the Grammy-nominated Alfredo, this album continues the celebrated partnership between Freddie Gibbs and The Alchemist. It was released in the summer of 2025.

The project features guest appearances from Anderson .Paak, Larry June, and JID, building on the refined, cinematic sound of its predecessor.

Promotion for the album included cryptic billboards and a short film titled Alfredo: The Movie, adding to the lore of the collaboration.

Key tracks:

• Ensalada (feat. Anderson .Paak)
• Shangri La

As the newest album in the discography, Alfredo 2 is still settling in with the fanbase. Following up a beloved, award-nominated album is always a difficult task.

Its current ranking reflects its freshness. Fans are still absorbing the album and deciding how it fits within the larger legacy of the Gibbs-Alchemist partnership.

---

14. Lord Giveth, Lord Taketh Away (2012)

This collaborative EP between Freddie Gibbs and producer Statik Selektah was reportedly recorded in a single 24-hour session in Brooklyn, New York.

Released in 2011, the project is a quick, potent showcase of the chemistry between the rapper and the prolific East Coast producer. It was praised by critics for its focus and energy.

Key tracks:

• Keep It Warm 4 Ya (feat. Smoke Dza & Chace Infinite)
• Lord Giveth, Lord Taketh Away (feat. Statik Selektah)

This EP is a deep cut for dedicated fans. Its short length and rapid creation give it a unique, spontaneous feel within Gibbs's discography.

While it might not have the grand scope of his full albums, it’s respected as a solid and enjoyable collaboration from two artists at the top of their game.

---

15. $oul $old $eparately (2022)

This 2022 release was Freddie Gibbs's major-label debut album, released through Warner Records. It followed a string of critically acclaimed independent and collaborative projects.

The album was a commercial success, peaking at number 11 on the Billboard 200 chart. It features a wide range of producers and high-profile guests like Pusha T and Anderson .Paak.

Key tracks:

• Feel No Pain (feat. Anderson .Paak & Raekwon)
• Gold Rings (feat. Pusha T)

As Gibbs's first major-label effort, $oul $old $eparately has a more polished sound than many of his other records.

Its placement on the fan ranking suggests that while commercially successful, some longtime listeners may prefer the grittier feel of his independent work. It's a high-quality album that stands slightly apart from the core fan favorites.

---

Picked your top Freddie Gibbs classic? Check out Freddie Gibbs's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Freddie Gibbs albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Freddie Gibbs's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Alfredo 2	2025
2	Alfredo	2020
3	Piñata	2014
4	Bandana	2019
5	You Only Die 1nce	2024
6	Fetti	2018
7	$oul $old $eparately	2022
8	Shadow of a Doubt	2015
9	You Only Live 2wice	2017
10	Cold Day In Hell	2012
11	Freddie	2018
12	Midwestgangstaboxframecadillacmuzik	2009
13	Baby Face Killa	2012
14	Str8 Killa	2010
15	Lord Giveth, Lord Taketh Away	2012

Quick FAQs about Freddie Gibbs's albums

Q: How did Freddie Gibbs and Madlib first connect to make Piñata?

A: They were introduced by Ben Lambo, who worked at Madlib's label, Stones Throw. Madlib provided Gibbs with over eight CDs worth of beats and let him choose the ones he wanted to write to.

Q: What was Freddie Gibbs's concept for Piñata?

A: Gibbs described the album as "a gangster Blaxploitation film on wax." He intended it to be a raw look at his flaws and past mistakes, without regrets.

---

So there you have it – a detailed look at the Freddie Gibbs albums ranked by the fans who know them best.

The rankings show a clear love for his groundbreaking collaborations, but every project holds a unique place in his story.

Ultimately, the best Freddie Gibbs album is the one that connects with you. What does your personal ranking look like? Let us know which album is your number one.