Faye Webster Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Faye Webster's music often feels like a secret you want to keep and share at the same time. Her blend of indie folk, R&B, and pedal steel creates a sound that is uniquely hers.

Because her songs are so personal and understated, debating the "best" Faye Webster album can feel like comparing diary entries. It’s a deeply subjective experience for every listener.

Here, we're taking a deep look at the Faye Webster albums ranked according to fan sentiment.

We'll also see how the discography stacks up based on current popularity data to get a fuller picture.

Ranking Faye Webster's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Atlanta Millionaires Club (2019)

Released in 2019, Atlanta Millionaires Club was Webster's first album on the Secretly Canadian record label.

This record truly cemented the signature sound fans adore today. It masterfully weaves together laid-back indie, soulful R&B grooves, and the distinctive cry of pedal steel guitar.

The album's title has a personal origin. It's named after a group of her father's friends from grad school who would compete in various contests.

Key tracks:

• Kingston
• Right Side of My Neck

Topping the fan-voted list, Atlanta Millionaires Club is often seen as the quintessential Faye Webster experience. It’s the record where all her influences coalesce perfectly.

For many listeners, this album was their entry point. Its lush, warm production and unforgettable melodies make it an enduring favorite in fan communities.

---

2. Faye Webster (2017)

Webster's self-titled sophomore album was released in 2017 through Awful Records.

This record marked a significant step in her artistic development. It showcased her growing confidence as a songwriter and a clearer sonic direction after her debut.

Faye Webster built the foundation for the sound she would perfect on her next album, introducing many to her unique lyrical perspective and genre-blending style.

Key tracks:

• I Know You
• She Won't Go Away

This album holds a special place for fans who were there just before her major breakthrough. It’s praised for its raw honesty and charm.

Its high ranking shows a deep appreciation for the moment Webster truly began to find the distinctive voice that would define her career.

---

3. I Know I'm Funny haha (2021)

Her fourth studio album, I Know I'm Funny haha, arrived in the summer of 2021 to widespread critical acclaim.

The record features some of her most beloved and specific songwriting. One track, "Better Distractions," was even included on Barack Obama's list of favorite songs of 2020.

Another song, "A Dream with a Baseball Player," was famously inspired by her crush on Atlanta Braves outfielder Ronald Acuña Jr., showcasing her wonderfully direct and humorous lyrical style.

Key tracks:

• In A Good Way
• A Dream With a Baseball Player

This album is celebrated by fans for its sharp wit and emotional vulnerability. The title track itself has become an anthem of sorts for its relatable, self-aware charm.

While not at the very top of the fan ranking, it’s arguably the album that brought her music to the largest audience yet, proving her songwriting continued to get stronger and more resonant.

---

4. Run and Tell (2013)

Run and Tell is where it all started. Webster self-released her debut album on October 30, 2013, at the age of just 16.

The record showcases a more Americana and folk-leaning sound, hinting at the melodic sensibilities she would later develop.

It's a fascinating look at the raw talent and songwriting instincts of a very young artist finding her voice.

Key tracks:

• Sweet Lad
• Give Me a Chance

For longtime fans, Run and Tell is a cherished document of Webster's origins. It provides a unique context for the incredible artistic journey that followed.

While her sound has evolved significantly, its placement in the ranking reflects its importance as the crucial first step rather than a go-to favorite for daily listening.

---

5. Underdressed at the Symphony (2024)

Webster's fifth studio album, Underdressed at the Symphony, was released in March 2024.

The album title was inspired by her own experiences of impulsively buying tickets to see the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra and not having time to change into formal attire.

Recorded at Sonic Ranch in Texas, the album sees her pushing her lyrical and sonic boundaries, blending catharsis and humor over an expansive, genre-fluid palette.

Key tracks:

• Thinking About You
• But Not Kiss

As the most recent release in her discography, this album's position may change as fans continue to live with it.

It's a more patient and sometimes challenging listen, which often means it takes longer to find its definitive place in a beloved catalog. Time will tell how its legacy evolves among listeners.

---

Picked your top Faye Webster classic? Check out Faye Webster's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Faye Webster albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Faye Webster's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Atlanta Millionaires Club	2019
2	Faye Webster	2017
3	I Know I'm Funny haha	2021
4	Underdressed at the Symphony	2024
5	Run and Tell	2013

Quick FAQs about Faye Webster's albums

Q: Where did the album name Atlanta Millionaires Club come from?

A: The title is named after a group of her father's friends from grad school. They compete in various contests, from eating doughnuts to running 5k races.

---

So there it is, a deep dive into Faye Webster albums ranked by the fans who know them best.

It's clear that while every album is a treasured part of her story, some eras resonate more deeply within the community.

Ultimately, the best Faye Webster album is the one that speaks to you. It's the one that feels like it was written just for a moment you were living.

What's your number one?