Fall Out Boy Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Ranking the discography of a band like Fall Out Boy is a fascinating exercise.

Their journey from scrappy pop-punk heroes to global arena-rock titans means every fan has a different favorite era.

To determine the best Fall Out Boy albums, we've looked primarily at fan sentiment and community discussion. This gives us a unique view of the Fall Out Boy albums ranked by the people who love them most.

We'll also explore a secondary ranking based on current popularity data to see which records are getting the most plays right now.

Ranking Fall Out Boy's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Infinity On High (2007)

Fall Out Boy's third studio album, Infinity On High, was a landmark release that saw the band experimenting well beyond their roots.

Released in 2007, it showed the band moving away from pure pop-punk to embrace more accessible pop, R&B, and soul influences.

The album features high-profile collaborations with artists like Babyface and an iconic intro from Jay-Z. It also introduced new instrumentation, including horns, pianos, and violins.

Infinity On High debuted at number one on the Billboard 200, becoming their first chart-topping album and solidifying their place as rock royalty.

Key tracks:

• Thnks fr th Mmrs
• This Ain't A Scene, It's An Arms Race

It’s no surprise to see Infinity On High land at the top spot. For a huge part of the fanbase, this record represents Fall Out Boy at the absolute peak of their creative and commercial powers.

Its seamless blend of ambitious, radio-friendly production with Pete Wentz's razor-sharp lyricism created a collection of songs that feel both massive and deeply personal.

---

2. From Under The Cork Tree (2005)

From Under The Cork Tree was the band's major-label debut and their mainstream breakthrough.

Released in 2005, it established the definitive songwriting partnership of Patrick Stump composing the music and Pete Wentz penning the lyrics.

The album was a massive commercial success. It earned the band their first top 10 album on the Billboard 200 and has since sold over 2.5 million copies in the United States alone.

Its themes tackle anxiety and depression, with Wentz's lyrics turning a critical eye inward.

Key tracks:

• Sugar, We're Goin Down
• Dance, Dance

This album is the quintessential mid-2000s emo and pop-punk touchstone. Its placement at number two reflects its monumental impact on an entire generation of music fans.

The unforgettable hooks and witty, verbose lyrics of songs like "Sugar, We're Goin Down" defined a moment in time and remain incredibly beloved today.

---

3. Save Rock And Roll (2013)

After a five-year hiatus, Fall Out Boy returned with Save Rock And Roll in 2013.

The album was recorded in secret and conceived as a major reinvention of the band's sound. They combined rock with pop and R&B, leaving longtime producer Neal Avron for Butch Walker.

It features an eclectic mix of guest vocalists, including Foxes, Big Sean, Courtney Love, and Elton John.

The comeback was a huge success, debuting at number one and revitalizing the band's career for a new decade.

Key tracks:

• The Phoenix
• My Songs Know What You Did In The Dark (Light Em Up)

Ranking third, Save Rock And Roll is celebrated by fans for being a triumphant return. It proved the band could not only survive a hiatus but come back stronger and more relevant than ever.

Fans appreciate the bold, declarative nature of the album and its anthemic, arena-ready sound that set the stage for their second act.

---

4. MANIA (2018)

Fall Out Boy's seventh studio album, MANIA, was released in 2018 after a delay to allow the band more time to perfect its sound.

It represented the band's most significant departure yet, leaning heavily into electronic, pop, and experimental sounds.

Despite mixed reviews from critics, the album was a commercial success, debuting at number one on the Billboard 200.

It also earned the band a Grammy nomination for Best Rock Album.

Key tracks:

• HOLD ME TIGHT OR DON’T
• Champion

The reaction to MANIA remains one of the most polarizing topics in the Fall Out Boy community, which explains its interesting position in the fan ranking.

Its heavy focus on electronic and pop production was a bold move. Some fans embraced the experimentation, while others found it a challenging departure from their rock roots.

---

5. Take This to Your Grave (2003)

Take This to Your Grave is the band's debut studio album, released in 2003 on indie label Fueled by Ramen.

Recorded on a tight budget, the album captured the band's raw energy and laid the groundwork for their future success.

It was during these sessions that Pete Wentz began to take a more serious role in lyric writing, creating the dynamic that would define the band.

The album is widely considered a blueprint for 2000s pop-punk and a vital touchstone for the genre.

Key tracks:

• Grand Theft Autumn / Where Is Your Boy
• Dead on Arrival

For many longtime fans, this album is a sacred text. It's the raw, unfiltered sound of a young band with everything to prove.

Its high standing shows a deep appreciation for the band's pop-punk origins. The energy and clever wordplay here built the foundation for everything that followed.

---

6. American Beauty/American Psycho (2015)

Released in 2015, American Beauty/American Psycho followed the successful comeback of their previous album.

The band wrote much of the music while on tour with Paramore, developing a sound built for stadiums.

Led by the massive, 8x Platinum single "Centuries," the album debuted at number one, giving the band their third chart-topping record.

The album heavily incorporates samples, from Suzanne Vega's "Tom's Diner" to the theme from The Munsters.

Key tracks:

• Centuries
• Immortals

This album contains some of the band's biggest modern hits, yet its placement suggests fans are somewhat divided on the overall collection.

While the singles were hugely successful, some listeners feel the album as a whole is less cohesive than the fan-favorite records ranked higher on this list.

---

7. Evening Out With Your Girlfriend (2003)

This 2003 release is the band's debut mini-LP, recorded on a low budget in just two days.

The rushed schedule left the band unhappy with the final product. They often cease to refer to it as their official debut album.

Uprising Records released it against the band's wishes, and later reissued a remastered version in 2005 without their involvement after their mainstream success.

Key tracks:

• Honorable Mention
• Pretty In Punk

As more of a demo collection than a fully realized album, Evening Out With Your Girlfriend is understandably ranked lower by most fans.

It's viewed as an interesting historical document. It offers a glimpse of the band's earliest sound before they found their footing on Take This to Your Grave.

---

8. Folie à Deux (2008)

Folie à Deux, released in 2008, is the band's fourth studio album and perhaps their most ambitious of that era.

The music, composed by Patrick Stump, and lyrics, penned by Pete Wentz, touched on decaying relationships and moral dilemmas with a political edge.

Recorded in relative secrecy, the album moved further from emo power chords toward a wider range of genres. It featured guests like Elvis Costello and Pharrell Williams.

It received favorable reviews but was less commercially successful than its predecessor, and its reception ultimately contributed to the band's hiatus.

Key tracks:

• I Don't Care - Single Version
• Headfirst Slide Into Cooperstown On A Bad Bet

Often hailed as a misunderstood masterpiece, Folie à Deux holds a complicated but passionate place in the hearts of fans.

Its initial lukewarm reception has evolved into a strong cult following. Many now celebrate its creative risks, lyrical depth, and incredible songwriting, even if it doesn't top the overall fan poll.

---

9. So Much (For) Stardust (2023)

So Much (For) Stardust marked the band's eighth studio album and their first in over five years.

The 2023 release reunited the band with producer Neal Avron, who had last worked with them on Folie à Deux.

Critically acclaimed, the album was seen as a return to a more guitar-oriented, pop-rock sound, blending their various eras while incorporating soul, funk, and orchestral elements.

It also marked their return to their original label, Fueled by Ramen.

Key tracks:

• We Didn’t Start The Fire (Bonus Track)
• Love From The Other Side

As the band's most recent work, the fan consensus on So Much (For) Stardust is still solidifying.

While many fans and critics praised it as a brilliant return to form, it takes time for a new album to build the deep nostalgic connection that older records possess. Its legacy is still being written.

---

10. Make America Psycho Again (2015)

This 2015 release is the band's first and only remix album.

It's a full reworking of their sixth album, American Beauty/American Psycho.

Each track on the album features a guest appearance from a different rapper, including artists like Migos, A$AP Ferg, and Wiz Khalifa.

The title and artwork allude to the political climate of the time.

Key tracks:

• Centuries - Remix
• Uma Thurman - Remix

As a remix album, Make America Psycho Again is naturally seen as a non-essential release by most of the fanbase.

It's an interesting experiment but doesn't hold the same weight as the band's original studio material, placing it at the bottom of the fan ranking.

---

Picked your top Fall Out Boy classic? Check out Fall Out Boy's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Fall Out Boy albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Fall Out Boy's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	American Beauty/American Psycho	2015
2	From Under The Cork Tree	2005
3	Infinity On High	2007
4	So Much (For) Stardust	2023
5	Take This to Your Grave	2003
6	Save Rock And Roll	2013
7	MANIA	2018
8	Folie à Deux	2008
9	Make America Psycho Again	2015
10	Evening Out With Your Girlfriend	2003

Quick FAQs about Fall Out Boy's albums

Q: Who were some of the notable collaborators on the fan-favorite album, Infinity On High?

A: The album featured several high-profile guests. This includes a famous spoken-word introduction from Jay-Z on the opening track and production work from R&B legend Babyface on two songs.

Q: Why did Fall Out Boy experiment with their sound so much on that album?

A: The band wanted to move beyond their pop-punk origins. They intentionally incorporated new genres like R&B and soul, and used instruments such as horns, pianos, and violins for the first time to create a bigger sound.

---

So there you have it, a detailed look at the Fall Out Boy albums ranked.

The lists show a fascinating split. Fan sentiment cherishes the classic 2000s era, while popularity data highlights the massive reach of their modern hits.

Ultimately, the best Fall Out Boy album is the one that soundtracks a key moment in your own life. Each record represents a different chapter in their story and ours.

What does your personal ranking look like?