Dayseeker Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Trying to rank the albums of a band like Dayseeker is a fascinating challenge.

Their discography shows a clear evolution, from raw post-hardcore beginnings to a more polished, synth-infused sound. This journey means different albums connect with different people for very different reasons.

Here, we're taking on the task of creating a Dayseeker albums ranked list. Our primary guide is fan sentiment, looking at which records have resonated most deeply within the community.

We'll also explore a secondary ranking based purely on current popularity data to see how the lists compare.

Ranking Dayseeker's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Sleeptalk (2019)

Sleeptalk is the fourth studio album from the Southern California post-hardcore band.

Released in 2019 through Spinefarm Records, the album was produced by Daniel Braunstein.

Critics noted that Sleeptalk represented a reinvention for the band, helping them step into the light and drive their career forward in a significant way.

Key tracks:

• Sleeptalk
• Burial Plot

It's no surprise to see Sleeptalk take the top spot among fans. This album is widely considered a masterpiece and a turning point in Dayseeker's sound.

The blend of ethereal soundscapes, Rory Rodriguez's soaring vocals, and deeply personal lyrics created a powerful connection with listeners that endures today.

2. Origin (2015)

Origin is the band's second studio album, released in 2015 via InVogue Records.

Produced by Nick Ingram, the record received almost exclusively positive reviews upon its release.

It was the band's first album to chart, peaking on the Billboard Heatseekers chart and selling over a thousand copies in its first week.

Key tracks:

• Hello
• The World Was Quiet

For a large part of the fanbase, Origin represents the perfect balance of Dayseeker's heavier roots and the melodic ambition they would later fully embrace.

The raw emotion and powerful lyrical themes on this album solidified their place in the scene and remain a high point in their discography for many longtime listeners.

3. Dark Sun (2022)

Dark Sun is the band's fifth studio album, released in late 2022.

Continuing their partnership with Spinefarm Records and producer Daniel Braunstein, this album saw the band lean further into a synth-heavy, atmospheric sound.

The record is a deeply emotional one, with frontman Rory Rodriguez exploring the grief that came with the loss of his father.

Key tracks:

• Without Me
• Neon Grave

Dark Sun's position shows a strong appreciation for Dayseeker's modern direction.

While it may have moved away from some of their heavier elements, fans have clearly connected with the album's vulnerability and polished, expansive sound. It's an emotionally heavy and beautifully crafted experience.

4. Replica (2024)

Replica is a unique entry in Dayseeker's discography, released in 2024.

This album features acoustic versions of popular songs from their previous two records, Sleeptalk and Dark Sun.

It also includes collaborations with artists like Caleb Shomo of Beartooth and Lucas Woodland of Holding Absence, along with a cover of "My Immortal" by Evanescence.

Key tracks:

• My Immortal - Acoustic
• Sleeptalk - Acoustic

The strong fan ranking for Replica speaks volumes about the quality of Dayseeker's songwriting.

Stripping these songs down to their acoustic core highlights the emotional weight and melodic strength that fans fell in love with in the first place. It's a testament to the power of the original compositions.

5. What It Means to Be Defeated (2013)

This is the debut studio album from Dayseeker, originally released in 2013.

Released through InVogue Records, the album was produced by Jeff Darcy and later mastered by the renowned Joey Sturgis.

A re-issued version was released in 2014, featuring re-mastered audio and four new acoustic bonus tracks.

Key tracks:

• Dead Man
• Black Earth

The band's debut album holds a special place for those who have been with Dayseeker from the very beginning.

While its lower ranking reflects the band's significant evolution in sound and production, this record's raw, unfiltered post-hardcore energy is undeniable. It laid the groundwork for everything that was to come.

6. Dreaming Is Sinking /// Waking Is Rising (2017)

Dreaming Is Sinking /// Waking Is Rising is the band's third studio album.

Released in 2017, it was their first with Spinefarm Records and was produced by Josh Schroeder.

The album features notable guest vocal performances from Garrett Russell of Silent Planet and J.T. Cavey of Erra.

Key tracks:

• Vultures
• Six Feet Under

This album is often seen as a transitional record, bridging the gap between the sound of Origin and the polished direction of Sleeptalk.

While it may not hold the top spot for most fans, it contains some of Dayseeker's most powerful and aggressive tracks, showcasing a band honing their craft and building toward their future sound.

7. Creature In The Black Night (2025)

Creature In The Black Night is the band's sixth full-length album, released in October 2025.

The album was first announced with the release of its title track single in July 2025.

It follows the release of a prior single, "Pale Moonlight," which also features on the record.

Key tracks:

• Pale Moonlight
• Creature In The Black Night

As a new album, the placement of Creature In The Black Night is based on early excitement and the strength of its lead singles.

Its final standing among fans is yet to be determined, but the anticipation is high. The early tracks suggest a continuation of the band's atmospheric and emotionally charged direction.

Picked your top Dayseeker classic? Check out Dayseeker's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

Dayseeker albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Dayseeker's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Quick FAQs about Dayseeker's albums

Q: Who produced Dayseeker's album Sleeptalk?

A: The album was produced by Daniel Braunstein, who also worked with the band on their follow-up album, Dark Sun.

Q: What record label was Sleeptalk released on?

A: Sleeptalk was released on September 27, 2019, through Spinefarm Records, which was the band's second release with the label.

So there you have it – a look at Dayseeker's albums ranked by both fan passion and current data.

It's clear that while the newer material is getting a lot of attention, the connection fans have with landmark albums like Sleeptalk is undeniable.

Ultimately, the best Dayseeker album is the one that means the most to you. Each record captures a different era and emotion.

What does your personal ranking look like?