Creeper Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the Creeper discography is an exercise in theatricality and passion.

Each album is a world unto itself, complete with narratives, characters, and a sound that evolves while staying true to their punk-rock heart.

Today, we're exploring the Creeper albums ranked by the people who know them best: the fans. This list is shaped by community sentiment to determine what many consider the best Creeper albums.

We'll also look at how their catalog stacks up based on current popularity data.

Ranking Creeper's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Sanguivore (2023)

Sanguivore is the third studio album from the English rock band, produced by Tom Dalgety.

Released in October 2023, it was the group's first record on Spinefarm Records.

The album's vampire-centric concept was inspired by the end of COVID-19 lockdowns, symbolizing a return to life and live music.

Key tracks:

• Cry To Heaven
• Lovers Led Astray

Landing the top spot, Sanguivore clearly made a massive impact on the Creeper fanbase right out of the gate.

Its blend of gothic rock and heavy metal, wrapped in a dramatic narrative, seems to be the exact evolution fans were waiting for.

2. Sex, Death & The Infinite Void (2020)

Creeper's second studio album, Sex, Death & The Infinite Void, was released in July 2020.

The album marked a stylistic shift from their horror punk roots, drawing influence from artists like Roy Orbison and David Bowie.

It's a concept album telling the story of an angel who falls from grace after experiencing love for the first time.

Key tracks:

• Cyanide
• Annabelle

This album holds a special place for many listeners. Its bold sonic reinvention could have been risky, but fans embraced the ambitious narrative and glam-rock swagger.

The record proved that Creeper could build entire worlds with their music, a quality that keeps it near the top of fan rankings.

3. Eternity, In Your Arms (2017)

Eternity, In Your Arms is the band's highly anticipated debut studio album, released in March 2017.

Produced by Neil Kennedy, the album is largely categorized as horror punk but also incorporates pop punk and glam rock elements.

The record is centered around the story of a fictional missing paranormal investigator named James Scythe, building on narratives from their earlier EPs.

Key tracks:

• Hiding With Boys
• Misery

The album that started it all. For longtime fans, Eternity, In Your Arms is pure, uncut Creeper.

It established the band's signature blend of punk energy and theatrical storytelling, creating a foundation that the rest of their discography is built upon.

4. Sanguivore II: Mistress of Death (2025)

Sanguivore II: Mistress of Death is the fourth studio album from the band.

Released on Halloween 2025, it serves as a direct narrative and thematic sequel to 2023's Sanguivore.

Tom Dalgety returns as producer for this continuation of the vampire saga.

Key tracks:

• Mistress Of Death
• A Shadow Stirs

As a new album, its placement here is based on sheer anticipation and the strength of its predecessor.

The promise of a direct sequel to a fan-favorite has generated immense excitement, though its true standing will only be known upon release.

5. American Noir (2021)

Released in July 2021, American Noir is an EP that serves as an "epilogue" to the story from Sex, Death & The Infinite Void.

The tracks were written during the sessions for their second album and explore the aftermath of the main story's conclusion.

The release notably features keyboardist Hannah Greenwood on lead or co-lead vocals for several tracks, portraying the character of Annabelle.

Key tracks:

• Midnight
• Ghosts Over Calvary

While technically an EP, American Noir functions as a crucial chapter in the Creeper saga.

Fans appreciate it as a beautifully crafted companion piece that adds depth to a beloved storyline, even if it doesn't stand as a full-length concept on its own.

Picked your top Creeper classic? Check out Creeper's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

Creeper albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Creeper's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Quick FAQs about Creeper's albums

Q: What was the main concept behind Creeper's album Sanguivore?

A: The album's vampire concept was directly inspired by the end of the COVID-19 lockdown. It explores themes of breathing new life into an old body and falling back in love.

Q: What are some of the musical influences on Sanguivore?

A: The band cited a wide range of influences, including The Sisters of Mercy, Danzig, and The Damned. They also drew inspiration from artists like Meat Loaf and Bruce Springsteen for specific tracks.

So there you have it – a look at Creeper's albums ranked.

We've considered both the passionate insights of fans and current engagement data.

Ultimately, the "best" Creeper album often comes down to personal connection. The moments those songs soundtrack in our lives are what matter most.

Each record is a distinct chapter. What does your personal ranking of Creeper's albums look like? Which one holds the top spot for you, and why?