Charlie Puth Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the discography of an artist like Charlie Puth always brings up a passionate debate among fans.

What is the definitive, best Charlie Puth album? Is it the breakout success, the critically acclaimed follow-up, or the modern, self-titled work?

To explore this, we are looking at the Charlie Puth albums ranked primarily by fan sentiment. We've analyzed community discussions and the general feeling surrounding each record to see which ones resonate most deeply.

Later, we'll see how this compares to current popularity data.

Ranking Charlie Puth's albums: The fan favorites

Here is how the studio albums stack up according to the fans. This ranking is built from the ground up based on community buzz, forum discussions, and overall sentiment.

We begin with the album that fans hold in the highest regard.

1. Voicenotes (2018)

Image from article: Charlie Puth Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

With his second album, Charlie Puth aimed for a significant sonic evolution. The record is a masterclass in funk-infused pop, showcasing incredible melodic complexity and production skill.

The album's title itself is a nod to his creative process. Puth famously uses the voice notes app on his phone to capture song ideas as they come to him.

The result was a project that felt both meticulously crafted and deeply personal, moving away from the more straightforward pop of his debut.

Key tracks:

Attention
How Long

It's no surprise to see Voicenotes at the top of the fan ranking. It represents a huge leap in artistry that was recognized by both critics and listeners alike.

Fans consistently praise its slick production, cohesive 80s and 90s funk vibe, and the maturity of its songwriting. For many, this is the album where Puth truly defined his signature sound.

2. Nine Track Mind (2015)

This is the album that started it all. Puth's debut studio album, Nine Track Mind, was released in 2016 after the massive success of his early singles.

It was a huge commercial success, delivering multiple chart-topping hits that cemented his place as a new force in pop music.

Despite its success, the album received largely negative reviews from critics. Even Puth has admitted in interviews that he was disappointed with how the final project turned out.

Key tracks:

We Don't Talk Anymore (feat. Selena Gomez)
One Call Away

Nine Track Mind holds a special place in the hearts of longtime fans. Its ranking here shows that commercial success and nostalgic connection can often mean more than critical scores.

The sheer power of its hit singles created a massive, dedicated following. For the fans who were there from the beginning, this album is pure nostalgia and the foundation of their appreciation for his work.

3. CHARLIE (2022)

Puth's third studio album, CHARLIE, arrived in 2022 as his most personal and publicly documented project to date.

The album's creation was shared extensively on social media, with Puth giving fans a behind-the-scenes look at his songwriting process.

It was led by a string of viral singles, including "Light Switch" and the collaboration "Left and Right" with Jung Kook of BTS.

Key tracks:

That's Hilarious
I Don’t Think That I Like Her

Landing at the third spot, CHARLIE is an album that fans respect for its vulnerability and pop craftsmanship, even if it hasn't quite overtaken his earlier works.

Its open-book creation on TikTok was a unique journey many enjoyed. However, it may still be too new to have built the same deep, nostalgic connection that defines the fan relationship with his first two albums.

Picked your top Charlie Puth classic? Check out Charlie Puth's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

Charlie Puth albums: A look at popularity data

Support Our Work

Listen great music, try 30 days of Amazon Music Unlimited on us. You get access to more than 100 million songs, we get a small kickback too.

Claim Your Free Month

While fan sentiment tells one story, current popularity data provides another interesting perspective.

This isn't about which album is "better," but which one is getting the most engagement right now.

Below is a ranking of Charlie Puth's albums based purely on their popularity scores from available streaming data.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Voicenotes	2018
2	Nine Track Mind	2015
3	CHARLIE	2022

Quick FAQs about Charlie Puth's albums

Q: How was Charlie Puth's third album, CHARLIE, promoted?

A: Puth used a very modern promotional strategy by teasing the creation of nearly the entire album on TikTok. This unique approach helped several songs go viral before they were even released.

Q: What were some of the key singles from the album CHARLIE?

A: The album was supported by many popular singles. These included the viral hit "Light Switch" and "Left and Right," a major collaboration with Jung Kook of BTS.

So, we have a complete look at Charlie Puth's albums ranked by both fans and data.

It's clear that while the slick, artistic statement of Voicenotes often takes the top spot, the nostalgic power of his debut holds strong.

Ultimately, the best Charlie Puth album is the one that connects with you the most. Each record offers a different snapshot of his journey as an artist.

What does your ranking look like?