Bombay Bicycle Club Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the Bombay Bicycle Club discography always starts a conversation.

It's a catalog filled with sharp turns, from nervy indie rock to acoustic folk and electronic soundscapes. Every fan has a fiercely defended favorite.

This guide to the Bombay Bicycle Club albums ranked is driven by the fans. We're looking at community sentiment to see which records resonate the most deeply. T

his offers a unique path to finding what many feel is the best Bombay Bicycle Club album, followed by a look at popularity data for another perspective.

Ranking Bombay Bicycle Club's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Everything Else Has Gone Wrong (2020)

Released in 2020, this album marked the band's return after a nearly six-year hiatus.

The band had announced an indefinite break in 2016, with members pursuing solo projects. Jack Steadman released music as Mr Jukes, and Ed Nash recorded as Toothless.

After deciding against a simple anniversary tour for their debut, the band focused on creating new music. They recorded with producer John Congleton in London and Los Angeles.

The album was met with favorable reviews and debuted at number one on the UK's Official Record Store Chart.

Key tracks:

• Eat, Sleep, Wake (Nothing But You)
• Everything Else Has Gone Wrong

Topping the fan-voted list, Everything Else Has Gone Wrong clearly holds a special place for listeners.

Its success as a comeback record, filled with both hope and anxiety, resonated powerfully. It felt like a triumphant return and a perfect summary of their journey so far.

---

2. A Different Kind Of Fix (2011)

A Different Kind of Fix is the third studio album from the band, released in 2011.

This record saw the band fuse their indie rock roots with more complex electronic elements and sampling. It was a significant step forward in their sound evolution.

It features the unmistakable backing vocals of Lucy Rose, who became a frequent collaborator.

Key tracks:

• Shuffle
• Lights Out, Words Gone

Coming in at number two, this album is a clear fan favorite for a reason.

Many fans see it as the moment the band truly found its unique, forward-thinking voice. The blend of intricate guitar work and inventive production made it a landmark release.

---

3. Flaws (2010)

Released just a year after their debut, Flaws was a bold and unexpected turn.

The band stripped back their sound entirely for a fully acoustic album. It included new material alongside covers of songs by Joanna Newsom and John Martyn.

The album was a critical and commercial success, reaching the top 10 in the UK and earning an Ivor Novello Award nomination for best album.

Key tracks:

• Ivy & Gold
• Rinse Me Down

The high ranking of Flaws highlights the fanbase's appreciation for the band's artistic courage.

This quiet, intimate record proved their songwriting could stand on its own, without the loud guitars of their first album. It's a testament to their versatility.

---

4. So Long, See You Tomorrow (2014)

The band's fourth album, released in 2014, pushed their sound further into electronic and world music.

It was written during frontman Jack Steadman's travels through India, Japan, and Turkey. This resulted in heavy use of samples and a wide range of instrumentation.

It was the first album produced by a band member, with Steadman taking the lead. The album debuted at number one on the UK Albums Chart and was shortlisted for the Mercury Prize.

Key tracks:

• Luna
• Home By Now

So Long, See You Tomorrow is often seen as the band's most ambitious and globally-influenced work.

While some fans were divided by the significant shift, many celebrate its vibrant, joyful, and richly textured production. It remains a creative high point in their discography.

---

5. I Had The Blues But I Shook Them Loose (2009)

The band's debut album, I Had the Blues But I Shook Them Loose, was released in 2009.

Recorded with producer Jim Abbiss, it captures the raw energy and youthful exuberance of their early indie rock sound. The album title is a nod to a line from the A Tribe Called Quest song "After Hours."

It established the band as a major new voice in the UK indie scene and received a generally positive reception from critics.

Key tracks:

• Always Like This
• Evening / Morning

For many longtime fans, this album is pure nostalgia. It's the sound of where it all began.

While their sound has evolved dramatically, the urgent, heartfelt anthems on their debut remain essential. Its ranking reflects a deep respect for their roots, even as other albums are more frequently revisited.

---

6. My Big Day (2023)

My Big Day is the band's sixth studio album, released in late 2023.

This album is notable for being produced by Jack Steadman and for its impressive list of collaborators. It features guest appearances from artists like Damon Albarn, Holly Humberstone, and Chaka Khan.

The record was met with critical acclaim, with reviewers praising its eclectic and adventurous spirit. It was celebrated as a creative milestone for the band.

Key tracks:

• Diving - feat. Holly Humberstone
• Turn The World On

As the newest entry in their discography, My Big Day is still finding its long-term place among fans.

Its lower fan-ranking likely reflects its freshness rather than a lack of quality. The album's playful, collaborative nature is a joy to listen to, and its standing will surely evolve as fans spend more time with it.

---

Picked your top Bombay Bicycle Club classic? Check out Bombay Bicycle Club's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Bombay Bicycle Club albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Bombay Bicycle Club's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	A Different Kind Of Fix	2011
2	I Had The Blues But I Shook Them Loose	2009
3	Everything Else Has Gone Wrong	2020
4	So Long, See You Tomorrow	2014
5	Flaws	2010
6	My Big Day	2023

Quick FAQs about Bombay Bicycle Club's albums

Q: Why did Bombay Bicycle Club go on hiatus before their album Everything Else Has Gone Wrong?

A: The band announced an indefinite hiatus in 2016 to allow members to focus on solo projects. Jack Steadman released music as Mr Jukes, and Ed Nash released an album as Toothless during this period.

Q: How did the band decide to record a new album instead of doing an anniversary tour?

A: While they initially discussed a tour for the 10th anniversary of their debut, they felt it wasn't appropriate for a relatively young band. Since they still had creative ideas, they quickly shifted focus to writing and recording new music together.

---

Ranking the discography of Bombay Bicycle Club shows just how much their sound has grown.

The fan list celebrates their journey, especially their triumphant return. The data, on the other hand, shows the lasting power of their earlier material.

Ultimately, the best Bombay Bicycle Club album is the one that connects with you personally. Each record offers a completely different world to explore.

What does your list of Bombay Bicycle Club albums ranked look like?