Baxter Dury Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Trying to rank the albums of an artist like Baxter Dury is a brilliant, if difficult, task.

His discography is a journey through wit, melancholy, and sharply observed vignettes of modern life. Each record has its own distinct flavour and devoted audience.

Here, we’re exploring the Baxter Dury albums ranked from top to bottom, using fan sentiment as our primary guide. This gives us a unique look at what many consider the best Baxter Dury albums, followed by a quick glance at how they fare based on current popularity data.

Ranking Baxter Dury's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. I Thought I Was Better Than You (2023)

Dury's seventh studio album was produced by Paul White, who is known for his work with artists like Charli XCX and Danny Brown.

The record features guest vocals from singer-songwriters Eska and JGrrey, adding new textures to his sound.

Upon its release, I Thought I Was Better Than You received favorable reviews and was supported by tours with Pulp.

Key tracks:

• Celebrate Me
• Crowded Rooms

Taking the top spot, this recent release clearly resonated powerfully with Dury's audience.

It's a perfect distillation of his modern style, blending autobiography with his signature spoken-word delivery over sharp, contemporary production. Its success with fans shows a deep appreciation for his evolving artistry.

---

2. Prince of Tears (2017)

Released on Heavenly Recordings, Prince of Tears was a significant moment in Dury's career.

The album features guest appearances from Jason Williamson of Sleaford Mods and Rose Elinor Dougall.

It received widespread acclaim, with some publications describing it as a career-best effort. Critics noted that the songwriting felt sharper and more pointed than on his previous works.

Key tracks:

• Miami
• Prince of Tears

For many, Prince of Tears is the definitive Baxter Dury album. It solidified the seedy, heartbroken narrator persona he's become known for.

The combination of lush arrangements and brutally honest lyrics created a modern classic that continues to be a huge fan favorite.

---

3. Len Parrot's Memorial Lift (2002)

This was Baxter Dury's debut studio album, introducing his unique voice to the world.

The preceding Oscar Brown EP had already garnered attention, earning a "Record of the Week" nod from NME in 2002.

The album laid the groundwork for the narrative style and atmospheric soundscapes he would explore throughout his career.

Key tracks:

• Beneath the Underdog
• Oscar Brown

The enduring love for his debut album shows a deep respect for where it all began.

Len Parrot's Memorial Lift is a rawer, more psychedelic listen than his later work, but the seeds of his lyrical genius are all there. It remains a cherished record for long-time followers.

---

4. It's a Pleasure (2014)

Released in 2014, this album saw Dury sign a new recording contract with the PIAS subsidiary, Le Label.

It's a Pleasure marked a distinct sonic shift, leaning more heavily into synth-led arrangements and a sleeker, more minimalist production style.

This album was a crucial step towards the sound that would define later successes like Prince of Tears.

Key tracks:

• Other Men's Girls
• Palm Trees

This album is a pivotal moment in his discography. It's where the louche, synth-pop sound truly came to the forefront.

Fans often point to this record as the bridge between his earlier, more organic style and the sharp-suited narrator of today.

---

5. Floor Show (2005)

Floor Show is Dury's second full-length album, released three years after his debut.

The album continued to build on his established persona, offering stark observations and character studies set to melancholic backdrops.

It represents a key period of development in his sound, further honing the lyrical style that would become his trademark.

Key tracks:

• Cocaine Man
• Sister Sister

Often considered an underrated gem, Floor Show is a darker and more brooding affair.

Its place in the middle of this fan ranking suggests it's a "grower" for many listeners—a mood piece that rewards patient listening.

---

6. The Night Chancers (2020)

Dury's sixth studio album was co-produced with his long-time collaborator Craig Silvey.

The record was created at Hoxa Studios in West Hampstead in May 2019.

The Night Chancers was released to critical acclaim, earning strong reviews from numerous music publications for its confident and refined sound.

Key tracks:

• I'm Not Your Dog
• Slumlord

Despite critical adoration, The Night Chancers lands a bit lower in the fan ranking.

This may be because it's one of his darkest and most cynical records. It's a challenging, cinematic album that perhaps resonates most with a specific subset of his dedicated fanbase.

---

7. B.E.D (2018)

This album is a unique collaboration between Baxter Dury, French dance music pioneer Étienne de Crécy, and Delilah Holliday.

The self-titled record was produced by de Crécy and Dury in France, blending their distinct styles into a cohesive project.

It stands as a fascinating detour in Dury's discography, exploring a more electronic and collaborative framework.

Key tracks:

• White Coats
• Only My Honesty Matters

As a collaborative project, B.E.D. naturally feels different from a solo Baxter Dury album.

While it's a fantastic and stylish electronic record, its ranking suggests fans connect most deeply with Dury's singular, unfiltered vision on his own albums.

---

8. Allbarone (2025)

Announced as Dury's ninth studio album, Allbarone sees him teaming up with acclaimed producer Paul Epworth.

The album was reportedly influenced by the live response to his dance-oriented collaborations, signaling a potential shift in his sound.

Recording took place quickly at Epworth's The Church studio in London, aiming to capture a spontaneous energy.

Key tracks:

• Allbarone
• Schadenfreude

As just released, Allbarone can't be fairly ranked among fans yet.

Its position here is simply a placeholder, but anticipation is incredibly high, especially with Paul Epworth at the production helm.

---

Picked your top Baxter Dury classic? Check out Baxter Dury's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Baxter Dury albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Baxter Dury's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	It's a Pleasure	2014
2	I Thought I Was Better Than You	2023
3	Floor Show	2005
4	Prince of Tears	2017
5	The Night Chancers	2020
6	B.E.D	2018
7	Len Parrot's Memorial Lift	2002
8	Allbarone	2025

Quick FAQs about Baxter Dury's albums

Q: Who produced Baxter Dury's album I Thought I Was Better Than You?

A: The album was produced by Paul White. He is celebrated for his work with artists like Charli XCX and Danny Brown.

Q: Are there any guest vocalists on I Thought I Was Better Than You?

A: Yes, the album features guest vocals from singer-songwriters Eska and JGrrey. His regular vocalist Madelaine Hart also appears.

---

So there it is—a detailed look at the Baxter Dury albums ranked by the fans who know them best.

From critical darlings to underrated gems, his catalog is rich and rewarding.

But the final verdict on the best Baxter Dury album always comes down to you. Which record do you think deserves the top spot, and what does your ranking look like?