Allie X Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the Allie X discography is a journey through sharp, inventive, and deeply personal synth-pop. Each album presents a different facet of her artistry, making any attempt to rank them a fascinating challenge.

We are setting out to explore the Allie X albums ranked from top to bottom. Our primary guide will be fan sentiment, pulling from community discussions and the general consensus that forms around an artist's body of work. This gives us a unique look at what many consider the best Allie X albums.

Later, we will also see how the records stack up based on current popularity data. Let's begin this exploration of Allie X's brilliant musical world.

Ranking Allie X's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Cape God (2020)

Released in 2020, Cape God is the second studio album from Allie X. It marked a shift towards a more personal and intimate style of songwriting for the artist.

The album's concept was inspired by the 2015 documentary Heroin: Cape Cod, USA. Allie X used the idea of a fictionalized Cape Cod to reflect on her own personal experiences and struggles.

Upon its release, Cape God received generally positive reviews from music critics, who praised its experimental edge and strong conceptual foundation.

Key tracks:

• Devil I Know
• Susie Save Your Love

Topping the fan ranking, Cape God is widely regarded as Allie X's magnum opus. Listeners connect deeply with its dark, narrative-driven lyrics and impeccable production.

The collaborations with Troye Sivan and Mitski are fan highlights, adding layers to an already rich and emotionally resonant project. It’s the album that many feel perfectly balances her avant-garde instincts with polished pop accessibility.

2. Girl With No Face (2024)

Girl With No Face is Allie X's third studio album, released in early 2024. The project was almost entirely written and produced by Allie X herself over the course of four years.

Described by the artist as "aggressive, indulgent and bold," the album explores themes of identity and transformation. Its sound is heavily inspired by 1980s synth-pop and new wave.

The album was met with universal acclaim from critics, who praised its creative autonomy and bold reclamation of artistic self.

Key tracks:

• Black Eye
• Weird World

Securing the second spot, Girl With No Face resonated strongly with fans for its confidence and artistic vision. Her direct involvement in nearly every aspect of its creation is a point of major appreciation.

The album's embrace of a ghoulish, '80s glam-rock aesthetic feels like a thrilling evolution, cementing its place as a modern fan favorite.

3. CollXtion II (2017)

Allie X's first official studio album, CollXtion II, arrived in 2017 after a unique development process. The record was built from a project titled CollXtion II: Unsolved.

For this project, she released a collection of demos and songs to her fans over the summer. This allowed her to shortlist the tracks that listeners connected with most for the final album.

This interactive approach resulted in a polished collection of synth-pop that directly reflected the tastes of her dedicated following.

Key tracks:

• Paper Love
• Downtown

Holding a firm spot in the middle of the pack, CollXtion II is cherished for its bright, anthemic synth-pop and the special bond created during its fan-involved conception.

It stands as a testament to the powerful connection between Allie X and her audience, filled with tracks that have become mainstays in her catalog.

4. CollXtion I (2015)

CollXtion I was the debut extended play that formally introduced the world to the Allie X persona in 2015. It followed her breakout 2014 single, "Catch."

The release established her signature sound, a blend of soaring pop melodies with darker, more complex lyrical themes. It served as a powerful mission statement for her career.

The EP was well-received and helped build the foundation of the dedicated fanbase that follows her to this day.

Key tracks:

• Bitch
• Catch

This is where it all began. For longtime fans, CollXtion I holds immense nostalgic value. It's the raw, unfiltered arrival of an artist who knew exactly who she was.

While her later work may be more sonically ambitious or conceptually grand, the pure pop perfection of this initial offering remains undeniable.

5. Super Sunset (2018)

Released in 2018, Super Sunset is an extended play that continued Allie X's exploration of identity and persona. It was followed by an alternate version titled Super Sunset Analog.

The project showcases a concise yet powerful collection of tracks that delve into different character archetypes, from "The Nun" to "The Sci-Fi Girl."

It bridges the gap between the collaborative nature of CollXtion II and the deeply personal storytelling of Cape God.

Key tracks:

• Girl Of The Year
• Science

Super Sunset is a potent and conceptual body of work that many fans admire for its sharp focus and theatrical flair.

Its standing in the fan ranking suggests it is seen as a crucial, character-driven chapter in her story, even if it isn't always the first full album fans reach for.

6. Happiness Is Going To Get You (2025)

Happiness Is Going To Get You is the new studio album from Allie X, released in late 2025.

It follows her critically acclaimed 2024 album, Girl With No Face. Early singles have started to give fans a glimpse of its direction.

Key tracks:

• 7th Floor
• Down Season

It is important to note this album's position in the fan ranking. Since it has not yet been released, its placement simply reflects a lack of established fan consensus.

This ranking is based on anticipation rather than reception. Once the full album is available, its place within Allie X's beloved discography will surely shift.

Picked your top Allie X classic? Check out Allie X's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

Allie X albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Allie X's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Quick FAQs about Allie X's albums

Q: What was the inspiration for Allie X's album Cape God?

A: The album was primarily inspired by the 2015 documentary Heroin: Cape Cod, USA. Allie X developed a fictionalized version of the location to process her own personal experiences.

Q: Who are the featured artists on Cape God?

A: The album features two vocal collaborations. Troye Sivan appears on "Love Me Wrong," and Mitski is featured on the song "Susie Save Your Love."

So there you have it – a look at the essential Allie X albums ranked by the fans who know them best. We have also seen how engagement data offers a different perspective.

Ultimately, the "best" Allie X album is a personal choice. Each record offers a unique world to get lost in, full of complex emotions and unforgettable hooks.

What does your ranking of Allie X's albums look like? Let us know which one stands as your personal favorite and why.