All Time Low Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the All Time Low discography always opens up a fantastic conversation among fans.

It's a catalog filled with raw pop-punk energy, polished anthems, and bold experiments. This makes deciding on the single best All Time Low album a truly personal choice.

Today, we're exploring the All Time Low albums ranked by the people who know them best: the fans.

We'll look at the records that have earned the most love in community discussions. Then, we will see how they stack up based on current popularity data.

Ranking All Time Low's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Put Up Or Shut Up (2006)

Released through Hopeless Records, the Put Up Or Shut Up EP was a pivotal early moment for All Time Low.

It features re-recordings of five songs from their debut album, The Party Scene. The tracks showcase a bouncy, energetic pop-punk sound that drew comparisons to genre giants like Fall Out Boy and New Found Glory.

This release helped solidify their place in the scene and has sold over 60,000 copies.

Key tracks:

• Coffee Shop Soundtrack
• Jasey Rae

It speaks volumes that an EP takes the top spot in the hearts of so many fans. Put Up Or Shut Up is pure, unfiltered lightning in a bottle.

For many, this collection represents the foundational sound and youthful abandon that made them fall in love with All Time Low in the first place. It’s the band at their most raw and essential.

---

2. Nothing Personal (2009)

The band's third studio album, Nothing Personal, was a commercial breakthrough that exceeded all expectations.

It debuted at number four on the Billboard 200, selling 63,000 copies in its first week. This record cemented their status as heavy-hitters in the pop-punk world.

The album spawned massive fan-favorites, including the lead single "Weightless" and the band's first Hot 100 entry, "Damned If I Do Ya (Damned If I Don't)".

Key tracks:

• Weightless
• Break Your Little Heart

Securing the second spot, Nothing Personal is often hailed as the definitive All Time Low album. It's the sound of a band firing on all cylinders.

It perfectly balanced their punk roots with a polished, radio-ready sheen, creating a collection of anthems that defined an era for countless fans.

---

3. Dirty Work (2011)

As their fourth studio album, Dirty Work marked the band's major-label debut with Interscope Records.

The recording process involved multiple producers, including Mike Green, Matt Squire, and Butch Walker. This led to a sound that vocalist Alex Gaskarth described as more pop-rock and alt-rock than pure pop-punk.

The album received a mixed-to-positive reception but charted well, reaching number six on the Billboard 200.

Key tracks:

• Time-Bomb
• I Feel Like Dancin'

Dirty Work is a fascinating and often-debated entry in the band's catalog, which explains its position here.

For some fans, its polished, pop-centric direction was a brilliant evolution. For others, it was a step away from their core sound. This split sentiment makes it a beloved, if slightly polarizing, record.

---

4. Last Young Renegade (2017)

The band's seventh studio album, Last Young Renegade, was their first release with Fueled by Ramen.

It represented a deliberate push into new sonic territories, with Gaskarth noting the band was exploring darker tones and reflecting on more mature themes.

The album debuted at number nine on the Billboard 200 and was met with generally positive reviews, with many critics praising the band's new, pop-influenced direction.

Key tracks:

• Good Times
• Drugs & Candy

This album saw the band embrace a more atmospheric and synth-heavy sound. Its ranking reflects an appreciation for the band's willingness to evolve.

Fans who connect with Last Young Renegade often praise its cohesive story and emotional depth, seeing it as a mature and ambitious work.

---

5. Don't Panic (2012)

Following their departure from Interscope, All Time Low returned to Hopeless Records for their fifth album, Don't Panic.

The band self-funded the recording sessions with producer Mike Green, aiming to create an album that reflected the best aspects of their previous releases.

The record was later reissued as Don't Panic: It's Longer Now!, which featured the hit collaboration "A Love Like War" with Vic Fuentes of Pierce the Veil.

Key tracks:

• Backseat Serenade
• Somewhere in Neverland

For many, Don't Panic felt like a triumphant return to form. It combined the polish of their major-label work with the raw energy of their earlier days.

Its solid standing with fans comes from its confident songwriting and its role as a "best of both worlds" album that reassured listeners the band was firmly in control of their destiny.

---

6. Future Hearts (2015)

The sixth studio album, Future Hearts, saw the band continue their relationship with Hopeless Records and producer John Feldmann.

The record became the band's highest-charting album, debuting at number two on the Billboard 200 and hitting number one in the UK.

It featured guest appearances from Mark Hoppus of blink-182 on "Tidal Waves" and Joel Madden of Good Charlotte on "Bail Me Out".

Key tracks:

• Kids In The Dark
• Something's Gotta Give

Future Hearts is an album packed with massive, arena-sized hooks. It's a commercially powerful record that brought the band to new heights of success.

While some fans felt it was overproduced in places, its ranking shows a strong appreciation for its ambitious scale and memorable singles.

---

7. So Wrong, It's Right (2007)

So Wrong, It's Right was All Time Low's second studio album and their proper debut on Hopeless Records.

Recorded with producers Matt Squire and Paul Leavitt, the album established the band's signature pop-punk sound. It delivered what would become their most iconic song, "Dear Maria, Count Me In".

Though it had a modest chart debut at number 62, the album achieved long-term success, eventually being certified Gold by the RIAA in 2017.

Key tracks:

• Dear Maria, Count Me In
• Remembering Sunday

It might seem surprising to see the home of "Dear Maria, Count Me In" this far down the fan ranking. However, it's often seen as the launching pad for the more refined sound of Nothing Personal.

While it’s a deeply loved and foundational record, some fans view it as the brilliant precursor to the band's absolute peak.

---

8. Wake Up, Sunshine (2020)

The band's eighth studio album, Wake Up, Sunshine, was their second release with Fueled by Ramen.

Largely created in a rented mansion in Palm Desert, the album was a conscious return to the band's pop-punk roots after the stylistic departure of their previous record.

It produced the single "Monsters," featuring blackbear, which became the highest-charting song of their entire career.

Key tracks:

• Monsters (feat. blackbear)
• Some Kind of Disaster

Hailed by many as a fantastic return to form, Wake Up, Sunshine blended the band's modern maturity with the classic sound fans adore.

Its lower placement in the fan ranking might simply be a matter of time. As a newer release, it may still be cementing its legacy compared to the classic, nostalgia-filled albums.

---

9. Tell Me I'm Alive (2023)

Tell Me I'm Alive is the band's ninth studio album and their third with Fueled by Ramen.

Written during the global shutdowns, the album's themes were heavily influenced by feelings of loneliness and the shared experiences of the pandemic.

The sound blends pop-rock and pop-punk, prominently featuring piano and synth elements. Alex Gaskarth described it as an "amalgamation" of their previous two records.

Key tracks:

• Sleepwalking
• New Religion (feat. Teddy Swims)

As the band's most recent effort, Tell Me I'm Alive is still finding its place within the broader discography.

Like any newer record, it takes time for its songs to become staples and for its full impact to be felt. Its current fan ranking reflects its freshness rather than a lack of quality.

---

Picked your top All Time Low classic? Check out All Time Low's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

All Time Low albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of All Time Low's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	So Wrong, It's Right	2007
2	Nothing Personal	2009
3	Wake Up, Sunshine	2020
4	Future Hearts	2015
5	Tell Me I'm Alive	2023
6	Don't Panic	2012
7	Last Young Renegade	2017
8	Put Up Or Shut Up	2006
9	Dirty Work	2011
10	Straight To DVD	2010

Quick FAQs about All Time Low's albums

Q: Are the songs on the fan-favorite release Put Up Or Shut Up all original to that EP?

A: No, five of the seven tracks on the EP are actually re-recordings of songs that first appeared on the band's 2005 debut album, The Party Scene.

Q: Where does the title Put Up Or Shut Up come from?

A: The title is taken directly from a lyric in the song "Break Out! Break Out!", which also originally appeared on The Party Scene and was re-recorded for the EP.

---

So there it is, our deep look at the All Time Low albums ranked.

We've seen how fan passion elevates the band's raw beginnings, while engagement data highlights the enduring power of their biggest hits.

Ultimately, the best All Time Low album is the one that means the most to you. It's the record that soundtracked a specific time in your life.

Now we want to hear from you. What does your personal ranking look like?