AJR Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the AJR discography is an adventure. The Met brothers have a unique sound that evolves with every release.

This journey often leads to a passionate debate among fans. Which record stands as their masterpiece?

Here, we explore the AJR albums ranked, letting fan sentiment lead the way. We'll look at which albums resonate most deeply within the community to find what many consider the best AJR albums.

Then, we'll see how that compares to current popularity data.

Ranking AJR's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Living Room (2013)

This is the debut studio album from AJR. It was released in 2015 under their own label, AJR Productions, and Warner Music Group.

Famously, the entire album was produced from the brothers' apartment in Chelsea, Manhattan.

It captures the raw energy and DIY spirit that first put the band on the map.

Key tracks:

• I'm Ready
• Pitchfork Kids

Taking the top spot, Living Room holds a special place for many longtime fans.

Its charm comes from its unpolished and inventive sound. This album represents the pure, unfiltered origin of a band that was just getting started.

---

2. Neotheater (2019)

Neotheater is the third studio album from AJR, released in 2019.

The self-produced record serves as a follow-up to their 2017 album, The Click.

It's described as a coming-of-age story. The album explores the sacrifices that come with growing older, pairing uplifting music with darker lyrical themes like anxiety and naivete.

Key tracks:

• 100 Bad Days
• Karma

As a fan favorite, Neotheater is celebrated for its ambitious, theatrical scope.

Listeners connect deeply with its cohesive narrative and grand production, which feels like a complete, immersive experience from start to finish.

---

3. The Click (2017)

Released in 2017, The Click is AJR's second studio album. This record truly defined their sound for a wider audience.

It contains some of the band's most recognizable hits, including their first Billboard Alternative number-one song, "Sober Up."

The album cemented their status as a multi-platinum band and showcased their knack for writing infectious electropop anthems.

Key tracks:

• Weak
• Sober Up - feat. Rivers Cuomo

Sitting comfortably in the middle of the fan ranking, The Click is the album that many feel everything "clicked" for the band.

It's filled with breakout singles that are foundational to the AJR live experience and represent a pivotal moment in their career.

---

4. OK ORCHESTRA (2021)

OK ORCHESTRA is AJR's fourth studio album, released in 2021.

Produced by Ryan Met, it features some of the band's biggest commercial successes. This includes the massive singles "Bang!" and "World's Smallest Violin."

The album earned AJR a Billboard Music Award for Top Rock Song and became their second top-10 album on the charts.

Key tracks:

• Bang!
• World's Smallest Violin

While an undeniable commercial juggernaut, OK ORCHESTRA lands a bit lower in the fan-specific rankings.

Its huge singles brought many new listeners into the fold, but some dedicated fans prefer the more conceptual or raw sounds of their other works.

---

5. The Maybe Man (2023)

The Maybe Man is AJR's fifth and most recent studio album, which arrived in 2023.

It marks the band's first release under Mercury/Republic Records.

The album tackles deeply personal and mature themes, partly shaped by the brothers' experience with their father's illness and passing.

Key tracks:

• Yes I'm A Mess
• Inertia

As the newest addition to the discography, The Maybe Man rounds out our fan ranking.

Its emotionally heavy and introspective nature is powerful, though it may take more time for it to find its long-term place in the hearts of the entire fanbase compared to their more established classics.

---

Picked your top AJR classic? Check out AJR's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

AJR albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of AJR's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	The Maybe Man	2023
2	OK ORCHESTRA	2021
3	The Click	2017
4	Neotheater	2019
5	Living Room	2013

Quick FAQs about AJR's albums

Q: How did AJR get their start?

A: The brothers began by busking in parks around New York City. They used the donations they earned to buy their first instruments and recording equipment.

Q: What was AJR's breakout single?

A: Their song "I'm Ready," from the album Living Room, was their breakout single. After Ryan Met tweeted the song to dozens of celebrities, the artist Sia took notice and helped connect them with their future manager.

---

So there you have it – a look at AJR's albums ranked.

We've considered both the passionate insights of fans and current popularity trends.

Ultimately, the "best" AJR album often comes down to personal connection. The moments those songs soundtrack in our lives are what matter.

What does your personal ranking of AJR's albums look like?