5 Seconds of Summer Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Diving into the 5 Seconds of Summer discography is a journey through modern pop-rock evolution.
From their energetic beginnings to their more refined, atmospheric sound, each album captures a distinct era. But which one truly resonates the most with their dedicated fanbase?
We're exploring the 5 Seconds of Summer albums ranked according to the fans. This list is built on community sentiment and discussion, offering a unique look at what many consider the best 5 Seconds of Summer album.
Let's see how their incredible catalog stacks up.
Ranking 5 Seconds of Summer's albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.
We're starting with the most beloved.
1. CALM (2020)
Released in 2020, CALM marked the band's fourth studio album. The title itself is an acronym for the first letters of the members' names: Calum, Ashton, Luke, and Michael.
The album was a huge commercial success, earning the band their fourth consecutive number one in Australia.
Critics praised CALM for its lyrical growth and maturity. It was even named one of the best pop albums of 2020 by Billboard magazine.
Key tracks:
- Teeth
- Easier
Securing the top spot, CALM is clearly a fan-favorite for a reason. It represents a significant step forward in the band's sound, blending dark, industrial-tinged pop with thoughtful introspection.
Many listeners feel this album is their most cohesive and artistically confident work to date, explaining its powerful connection with the fanbase.
2. Youngblood (2018)
The band's third studio album, Youngblood, arrived in 2018. It was a pivotal release that showcased a notable shift in their musical direction.
Reviews were largely positive, with critics highlighting the band's lyrical maturity and new sound.
The title track became an international mega-hit. It stands as the most streamed Australian song of all time on Apple Music and sold over five million copies worldwide.
Key tracks:
- Youngblood
- Ghost Of You
While its title track was a massive commercial force, the album as a whole holds the number two spot for fans.
Youngblood is seen as the bridge between their pop-punk roots and the more polished, darker pop they would later embrace. It's an album full of anthems that defined a new era for the group.
3. 5 Seconds Of Summer (2014)
The self-titled debut from 5 Seconds of Summer introduced the band to the world in 2014.
This album is powered by high-energy pop-punk and incredibly catchy hooks. It delivered massive hits that quickly established them as a global phenomenon.
The record was a huge commercial success, laying the foundation for their entire career with its infectious energy and relatable lyrics.
Key tracks:
- She Looks So Perfect
- Amnesia
Ranking third, the debut album holds a special place for many longtime fans. It's pure, unfiltered nostalgia.
While the band has evolved significantly since, the raw fun and youthful exuberance of this record are undeniable. It’s the sound of four kids from Sydney taking on the world.
4. 5SOS5 (2022)
5SOS5 is the band's fifth studio album, released in 2022. On this project, the band took on a larger role in writing and production.
The album's lyrical content was described by Luke Hemmings as "extremely introspective," reflecting the band's growth over their decade-long career.
It debuted at number one in the UK and Australia and number two in the US, continuing their impressive chart success.
Key tracks:
- Bad Omens
- Me, Myself & I
Coming in at number four, 5SOS5 is the band's most recent and arguably most expansive work. It's a sprawling album that showcases their refined production skills.
While some fans deeply connect with its mature and atmospheric sound, its quieter, more reflective nature might explain why it sits behind their more immediate, high-energy albums for now.
5. Sounds Good Feels Good (2015)
Following their massive debut, 5 Seconds of Summer released their sophomore album, Sounds Good Feels Good, in 2015.
The album continued their pop-rock sound but delved into more serious themes like depression and mental health. The band has stated the writing process was a way to work through personal issues.
It was another commercial success, debuting at number one in the US and UK. This made them the first band (not vocal group) to have their first two full-length albums debut at number one in the US.
Key tracks:
- She's Kinda Hot
- Jet Black Heart
Rounding out our fan ranking, Sounds Good Feels Good is an ambitious and important album in the band’s catalog.
Its darker lyrical themes were a bold step, and while tracks like "Jet Black Heart" are fan anthems, the album as a whole is often seen as a transitional work. It paved the way for the sonic shifts to come on Youngblood and CALM.
Picked your top 5 Seconds of Summer classic? Check out 5 Seconds of Summer's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.
5 Seconds of Summer albums: A look at popularity data
Support Our Work
Listen great music, try 30 days of Amazon Music Unlimited on us. You get access to more than 100 million songs, we get a small kickback too.
Claim Your Free MonthWhile fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.
This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.
Below is a ranking of 5 Seconds of Summer's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.
| Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Youngblood | 2018 |
| 2 | CALM | 2020 |
| 3 | 5 Seconds Of Summer | 2014 |
| 4 | 5SOS5 | 2022 |
| 5 | Sounds Good Feels Good | 2015 |
Quick FAQs about 5 Seconds of Summer's albums
Q: What does the album title CALM stand for?
A: CALM is an acronym created from the first letters of each band member's name: Calum, Ashton, Luke, and Michael.
Q: Was there anything unusual about the release of CALM in the US?
A: Yes, due to a shipping error, around 11,000 copies were released early in the United States. This caused the album to chart a week before its official release date.
So, we have the definitive list of 5 Seconds of Summer albums ranked by the fans.
The results show a deep appreciation for the band's artistic growth, with their more mature works taking the lead.
Ultimately, the best 5 Seconds of Summer album is the one that means the most to you. Each record is a snapshot of a time and place, for both the band and their listeners.
What does your personal ranking look like?